This is the story of two close brothers, one white (Eric), one black (Thomas), separated when about 6 and reunited at about 20. The two have vastly different lives during their separation. Yet, which one is the "fortunate son" is a moot point. Further details would not really be spoilers, but would be irrevalent and misleading. The specific plot, per se, does not matter. Like a magnificent painting, the story changes as you view it from different angles, and the longer you dwell on it. Ultimately, it is a story about fate. In this case, the hand of fate is very heavy.
Superficially, some of the events are a tad implausible and some characters larger than life---but this is a vivid uplifting grand allegory of great depth, power, and complexity. As such, "suspension of disbelief" isn't an issue.
What is the allegory about? After considerable reflection, I've concluded that the underlying theme is the Black experience in America. Okay, as a typical White guy, I would not find that description appealing. Don't be put off by that description/conclusion. The underlying theme is at most extremely subtle, not "in your face", nor antagonistic toward Whites. However, the eyes of a Black author may be more attuned to the question of fate. All of us are minorities of one, each struggling with our own fate---the lessons of the book are universal.
Okay, I suppose that I'm suppose to complain about something to demonstrate my "sophistication". The only thing that bothered me is the temporal disconnect after the brothers are separated. Chapters in which Thomas is 5 are followed by Eric at 14, back to Thomas at 6, to Eric at 15. The discontinuities were a bit jarring.
This is a story which will stay with me for a long time. I look forward to re-reading it at long, but regular, intervals. This is one to buy in hardcover.
less
0 comments
Post a comment