This book's title should win an award for obviousness. Of COURSE boys and girls learn differently, that is part of what makes them boys and girls. I think Gurian's book is addressing the educational fetish that all children are blobs of goo, entirely shaped by their upbringings. It is clearly not so... kids are hard-wired at birth and a one-size-fits-all education isn't going to work. It will frustrate the children, confound the teachers, and impart little actual learning.
The first section of the book is a rehashing of the brain research associated with early childhood development. This was spelled out better in Gurian's book The Minds of Boys. I suspect it was included in this book assert the author's theories' credibility. The second section of the book, on designing classrooms to meet the needs of boys AND girls, is extremely valuable.
A 25-year veteran teacher and I were talking about it. She says school is designed by women, taught by women, and geared toward women. Sit down, sit still, raise your hand. As a result, boyishness is becoming a pathology. There is nothing wrong with most boys, other than being biologically unsuited for an environment of "sit down, sit still, and raise your hand."
I teach 3-year old Sunday School, and boys and girls DO learn differently. It might not be a bad idea to sex-segregate preschoolers in Sunday school, rather than divide them by age. Most three-year-old girls can turn out a prettily colored picture or cutting craft; most three year old boys simply do not. However, when it comes to acting out a Bible Story, the boys are as engaged as the girls. And when you can put the kids INTO the lesson, the learning sticks.
The entire second section of this book is devoted to how to build inclusive lesson plans that meet the needs of all kids, and how to incentivize learning for boys and girls. It has been extremely helpful to me; I think this is the most helpful book I have read about reaching and training children since Karen Pryor's book "Don't Shoot the Dog."
less
0 comments
Post a comment