The State of European Tech 2015


Published on

Atomico & Slush State of European Tech. Special thanks to our data partners Crunchbase, Meetup, Stack Overflow, and Glassdoor.

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

The State of European Tech 2015

  1. The State of European Tech November 2015 November 2015SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech1 #whatsnext4eutech
  2. The State of European Tech 1. Introduction 2. Entrepreneurial Mindset 3. Tech Community 4. Talent 5. Capital Flows 6. Europe’s Success Stories 7. The Future 8. Appendix November 2015SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech2 #whatsnext4eutech
  3. 1. Introduction November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  4. Achievement unlocked. But not mission accomplished. 4 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech November 2015 Like successful companies, successful ecosystems go through distinct stages – and 2015 has been a breakthrough year for Europe. 5 years ago, major questions remained. Could Europe give birth to companies with real scale? Could it produce enough talent and overcome the cultural barriers to entrepreneurship? Could it attract significant VC funding - and would the IPOs ever come? Based on one of the most comprehensive studies ever undertaken into European tech, 2015 has conclusively answered these questions with a series of milestones: •  10 European software companies reaching billion-dollar valuations (making a total of 35 since 2003) •  on track for more than $10B invested in European tech startups •  over 5,000 active angel investors •  1.6m professional developers •  ...and over 100 tech IPOs in the last five years Achievement unlocked. But not mission accomplished. The next stage will bring its own challenges. How do we produce companies valued in the tens or hundreds of billions? How do we bridge the late stage funding gap? How do we unlock our potential by bringing our hubs closer together, and overcoming an alarming gender imbalance? By addressing these challenges, can Europe create an ecosystem self-sustaining enough to weather any future economic shocks? By setting out where we are today in an unprecedented level of detail, we hope this study also helps to show the way to what’s next. Niklas Zennstöm Founder and CEO Atomico Riku Mäkelä CEO Slush Source: Atomico, CrunchBase, Angel List, Stack Overflow Developer Insights, CapitalIQ #whatsnext4eutech
  5. Atomico and Slush 5 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech Atomico is an international investment firm, focused on helping the world’s most disruptive technology companies scale and become global leaders. Founded in 2006 by Niklas Zennström, a co-founder of Skype, Atomico has made over 50 investments across four continents. Slush is a not-for-profit technology and startup event, organized annually in Finland, Japan and China. In 2015, the Slush event in Helsinki drew together 15,000 entrepreneurs, investors and journalists from close to 100 countries. The mission of Slush is to encourage the next generation of brilliant minds to become entrepreneurs, and to catalyze tech communities across the globe. November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  6. Our data partners SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech6 Stack Overflow is one of the smartest and most helpful corners of the Internet. It’s the place where millions of developers go to learn, share their knowledge, and advance their careers. With nearly 30 million monthly visitors and 10.2 million programming questions, Stack Overflow has unparalleled insights into how developers think, what matters to them and what gets them excited. Stack Overflow's Developer Insights team works with employers around the world to help them understand regional and localised distribution of technical talent and provides consultancy services around attracting and engaging with programmers. CrunchBase is the leading platform used by millions of entrepreneurs, investors, and analysts looking to discover innovative companies and the people behind them. Founded in 2007 by Mike Arrington, it began as a simple database to track startups covered on TechCrunch. Today, CrunchBase delivers market insights to millions of users and businesses around the world. The CrunchBase Dataset is constantly expanding through contributions from its community of users, investment firms, and network of global partners. CrunchBase accelerates innovation by bringing together data on companies and the people behind them. For more information, please visit Meetup is a global network of local communities, built by ordinary people around the things they care about the most. Using the Meetup app or website, you can find people in your town who are into the same things you are, and build a real community around that interest. There are currently 24 million members in over 200,000 Meetups in over 180 countries. Meetup believes that people can change their personal world, or the whole world, by organizing themselves into groups that are powerful enough to make a difference. Glassdoor is the most transparent jobs and recruiting marketplace that is changing how people search for jobs and how companies recruit top talent. Glassdoor combines free and anonymous reviews, ratings and salary content with job listings to help job seekers find the best jobs and address critical questions that come up during the job search, application, interview and negotiation phases of employment. For employers, Glassdoor offers recruiting and employer branding solutions to help attract high-quality candidates at a fraction of the cost of other channels. Glassdoor, which has over 10m reviews, salaries and other types of content across more than 190 countries, operates one of the most popular job apps on iOS and Android. The company launched in 2008 and has raised approximately $160 million from Google Capital, Tiger Global, Benchmark, Battery Ventures, Sutter Hill Ventures, DAG Ventures, Dragoneer Investment Group, and others. November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  7. Survey and opinion formers 7 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech When it comes to the state of European tech, facts and figures can only get you so far. They can help you identify how much is being raised and where the investments are going but they cannot help you analyse how people are feeling, how confident they are and whether their mindsets have changed. These are all important questions and so we decided to supplement our fact-finding analysis with a survey of entrepreneurs, investors and other tech stakeholders. In October 2015, we sent out the survey to people in our European network and received over 800 responses from people with a direct interest in European tech. We have incorporated the findings into this report. See Appendix for more details. To provide additional context we also interviewed some of Europe’s leading entrepreneurs and investors and you will find their insights throughout. November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  8. 2. Entrepreneurial Mindset November 2015 Achievement unlocked: culturally acceptable in Europe to be a tech entrepreneur What’s next: investors need to keep pace with scale of ambition #whatsnext4eutech
  9. Europeans embrace entrepreneurship as a culturally acceptable career choice as it finally passes the “parent test” SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech9 Statement: It is culturally acceptable in Europe to be an entrepreneur Founders and investors agree…* …as do employees of startups and other businesses* The future looks bright for students… …and for young people in general Strongly agreeStongly disagree I don’t know 49% Disagree 5% 0% Agree 14% 33% 27% 35-44 18% 41% 14% 18-2445-54 25-34 34% 55+ 13% I don’t knowDisagree 17% 10% 10% 80% 70% Agree Founders Investors 8% 80% Agree 75% 9% I don’t know 14%11%11% 78% Disagree 14% Public sector Startup employees Corporate employees “I strongly agree”, by age group * Note: Strongly disagree and disagree, and strongly agree and agree have been added together Source: Slush & Atomico Survey Student respondents only November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  10. Entrepreneurship is now attracting the brightest minds from corporate careers and education SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech10 Q: What were you doing immediately before you founded your company? (founders only) 18% 47% 6% 28% Working for a company that wasn’t a startup Studying Working for another startup Other Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “I think what has happened is that the brightest of the brightest are no longer choosing banking or consulting as their default profession. Being an entrepreneur is now up there as a preferred choice.” Brent Hoberman, Founders Forum “What we have seen, is that people tend to go from working at a safe company like Ericsson, to actually trying to experience the life of working for a startup. But this wasn’t the case 5 years ago – back then you were insane if you joined a startup. That has definitely changed.” Alan Mamedi, Truecaller November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  11. Europe’s founder base is now stacked with repeat entrepreneurs SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech11 Q: Is your current company the first company you started? (founders only) 38% first-time founders 62% repeat founders Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “There is an increasing number of serial entrepreneurs and for example we have three cases in which we have already invested in an entrepreneur’s first and second company. There is an increasing amount of ambitious entrepreneurs who already master startup fundamentals.” Petteri Koponen, Lifeline Ventures November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  12. Statement: I would rather take risks and fail than choose the safe option European founders are not afraid of failure… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech12 8% 16% 4%3% Disagree Agree 76% 89% 76% 16% 20% 75% I don’t know 8% 9% Startup employeesFounders AllInvestors Note: Strongly disagree and disagree, and strongly agree and agree have been added together Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “Being an entrepreneur is now a viable career choice. People are ready to take risks and are just going off and starting companies.” Christian Hernandez, White Star Capital November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  13. … and although most think big and long-term, there is still some short-term orientation SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech13 Q: What are your goals for your startup? Most founders are thinking really big and long-term… …but some are still focused on Europe or the next milestone 158 responses “world domination” “grow and conquer the world” “change an industry and create mindblowing things” “become a global leader, a defining company for our sector” “become a monopoly in our field” “building a sustainable company that takes an entire industry upside down empowered by technology” 73 responses “50 employees and 5M€ revenue by end 2017, present physically in 5 countries” “build a successful internet firm employing 5-10 people or exit in a year's time” “getting funding” “grow bootstrapped, then exit after we've grown to the right size” “make €1m this year” “raise capital and visibility” “selling it in the next 2 years” Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  14. European founders have global ambitions, but many focus on their domestic market first before thinking of international expansion SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech14 43% "Entrepreneurs mostly think and act with a domestic mindset" 46% 9% "Entrepreneurs always think and act with a global mindset" 36% 44% "Entrepreneurs mostly think and act with a global mindset" 3% "Entrepreneurs think and act domestically, but have some international ambitions" "Entrepreneurs only think and act with a domestic mindset” 10% 1% 8% 0% Investors Founders •  Many European founders will focus on their domestic market and nearby markets first, before thinking about going global •  While almost no founders or investors believe European entrepreneurs think only domestically, there is still room to improve the global mindset of Europe’s entrepreneurs Q: How would you describe the international mindset of European entrepreneurs? Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “I think today every industry is thinking more and more global. Just in the past five years there’s been a huge perception shift. The advice I would give to the next generation of entrepreneurs is to think big, think global. You should have goals set immediately, even though reaching them could take a long time. Let’s put it this way: if you have your goals set on a level that makes you slightly uncomfortable, you’ve probably set them right.” Petri Järvilehto, Seriously November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  15. International expansion is key to achieving billion-dollar success… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech15 It’s incredibly rare to build a domestic $B firm in Europe… …so startups from small markets must internationalise faster 96% 19% 77% 81% 23% 4% USAsiaEurope •  International expansion is faster when you come from a small market - averaging just 1.4 years for companies with a domestic population of less than 50m, less than half the time of companies from countries with a population of over 50m people •  This is critical to success - every company from a country with less than 50m population went international before hitting a billion-dollar valuation InternationalDomestic only % of $B+ companies that scaled internationally to reach $B+ valuation Time to international expansion in years, by home market population 3.3 2.9 1.4 150m+50-150mUnder 50m Source: Atomico November 2015#whatsnext4eutech "We’re seeing that no matter where companies start out, the great ones can scale internationally faster than before and disrupt established players anywhere in the world. Every company from a country with less than 50m people went international before reaching a billion-dollar valuation." Carolina Brochado, Atomico
  16. Share of non-native employees in founders’ companies …fortunately, most European startups are born with a native international mindset and an inherent competitive advantage SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech16 Many European startups start with an international blend… ...and become even more internationally diverse as they grow 0-25% 15% 58% 26-50% 12% 50-75% 76-100% 15% 56% NativeNon-native 44% Source: Slush & Atomico Survey Q: What percentage (%) of your employees are not native to the country where your company is based? “Today we have a very diverse team - about 40 nationalities. And we have kept this strategy as it’s been helpful for scaling the company around the world - it’s been much faster because we have the in-house knowledge of these markets. For example, when we scaled into India, Alan and I had never been there, and the same goes for Lebanon. And these have now become key markets for our growth - so it’s really helpful to have an international employee base.” Alan Mamedi & Nami Zarringhalam, Truecaller November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  17. Brent Hoberman, Founders Forum “European entrepreneurs instinctively know that their domestic markets are too small so they take it internationally from much earlier on. As a result, Europeans often have to deal with multidimensional complexity much earlier on than American entrepreneurs.” In their own words SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech17 Brynne Herbert, MOVE Guides “The decision to start MOVE Guides in London has always been about 3 things: time zone, connectivity, and talent. On talent, London gives me and MOVE Guides a diversity of perspective. London is a natural melting pot of people from across Europe and from other countries. We feel very strongly that it brings unique perspective into the company and fosters innovation. It provides diversity in teams, which gives a lot of different benefits to the organization. At MOVE Guides, we have about 30 different nationalities on our team today, and it's absolutely contributed to many of the pieces of innovation that we've fostered, and also, is a big part of our culture.” Daniel Ek, Spotify “I just had this itch, I wanted to fix a problem. And because this was something that people in all countries face, I had to take a global approach in order to fix it.” Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  18. Achievement unlocked: large and highly-engaged tech communities What’s next: build closer links between our disparate hubs 3. Tech Community November 2015#whatsnext4eutech Source:
  19. Source: * 2015 is YTD to October 2015 Europe’s leading hubs host large and active tech communities SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech19 Top 20 hubs with tech-related Meetup communities, 2015, ranked by # of attendees at Meetup events 25.7 Paris 46.4 Berlin London 62.6 Hamburg 12.5 Barcelona Brussels 10.0 Zurich 10.5 6.9 6.28.4 Copenhagen Oslo 16.818.0 16.0 15.9 Budapest Stockholm Munich Madrid 13.5 Dublin Amsterdam 14.4 160.5 167.6 Other 5.1 4.9 Moscow Istanbul Manchester Vienna 6.1 5.3 Bristol ,000 of tech Meetups 3912 1519 1543 872 609 571 384 480 549 475 398 530 296 222 336 213 168 11504549 541 172 More than 630k people have attended one of 25k tech-related Meetups in Europe in 2015* November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  20. There has been significant growth in the levels of tech community engagement across all established tech hubs in Europe… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech20 Tech-related Meetups and event attendees (RSVPs) in selected European tech hubs London Berlin Stockholm Helsinki 1,265 5,216 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 0 50 200 150 100 2015* 4,400 20142013 3,281 20122011 2,214 Meetups RSVPsMeetups ,000 RSVPs 45 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 40 50 10 20 30 0 801 2,057 2014 210 2012 2015* 1,495 20132011 RSVPs Meetups Meetups ,000 RSVPs 732 620 44 0 200 400 600 800 0 10 5 20 15 2013 531 2012 2014 194 2011 2015* RSVPs Meetups Meetups ,000 RSVPs 178.7 132.0 0 100 200 4 1 2 3 0 2011 25.0 57.0 2012 19.0 2015*20142013 Meetups RSVPsMeetups ,000 RSVPs Source: * 2015 YTD extrapolated for rest of year from September November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  21. …and there are also dozens of hubs with fast-growing tech communities emerging across the continent SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech21 Top 15 fastest-growing hubs by number of tech-related Meetup communities* Annual growth +125% +108% +106% +97% +89% +78% +76% +72% +72% +71% +70% +65% +65%+93% +74% 3642 1712 23 5963 1213121717131217 98 115 49 35 68 175 191 374143 6366 5552 86 Lisbon Hamburg Copenhagen Istanbul Lyon Bucharest Prague Zagreb Munich Madrid Moscow Ljubljana Cologne Stuttgart Frankfurt 2013 2015 YTD # of tech-related Meetup groups by city Source: * Based on all hubs that had at least 10 active tech-related Meetup groups in 2013. YTD up to October 2015. “We are already seeing a change in attitudes and it is pretty amazing. We are seeing that people don’t just want to work in a start-up, but want to create a start-up. In 2012 this was unheard of, so this has all happened in just three years in Lisbon. It’s crazy exponential change for the better in Portugal” Anthony Douglas, Hole19 November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  22. Europe is building a strong base of mentors and every success story is helping create a new pool of role models for the next generation SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech22 Statement: I am able to turn to supportive mentors to help me when I face a challenge in growing my business 24% 20% 15% 5% 36% Strongly agreeAgree 30% 11% 14% 41% 23% 28% I don’t know 20% Disagree 22% Strong disagree 6% 4% All founders Repeat founders First-time founders Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “In my first five years I got really poor advice, and I just hate the fact that there may be talented people out there with the opportunity to grow a global business, receiving poor advice too. That is why I am more than happy to give advice to others. It feels like the right thing, and of course it gives me energy as well. I get a lot of energy from meeting these people that are ten years younger than me and are doing something really cool and new and fresh and they're not suffering from the challenges you have as a larger company.” Sebastian Siemiatkowski, Klarna November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  23. Earlier European success stories have already created a pool of stars that have remained as active participants in local ecosystems SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech23 European tech “mafias” Selected associated companies”Mafia” Selected members Ahti Heinla, Asko Oja, Jaan Tallinn, James Bilefield, Janus Friis, Jonathan Christensen, Niklas Zennström, Taavet Hinrikus, Sten Tamkivi, Daniel Ek, Jacob de Geer, Martin Lorentzon, Rene Rechtman Adam Valkin, Alex Chesterman, Mark Livingstone, Mike Blakemore, Saul Klein, Simon Calver Source: CrunchBase, LinkedIn Benoit Portoleau, Franck le Quay, Frédéric Clement, Greg Coleman, Julien Simon, Maxime Agostini, Pascal Gauthier, Tom Triscari, Tristan Croiset November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  24. Founders now believe they can build their companies from Europe SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech24 Q: If you were to start over, where would you choose to found and build your company? 7% 17%A different European city I would choose to stay where we are now 62% A different US city 2%Elsewhere 12%Bay Area/Silicon Valley Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “I declined an offer from a US investor, because it came with the caveat of "move to the US and we’ll invest". I said "ok then we’re done". It doesn’t make sense for us to move to the US because we’ve proven we can build something out of Lisbon. It's unnecessary to pay 5 or 10x, to significantly increase my burn to do the same thing somewhere else when we have the talent and know-how to build product locally. We may need some biz dev here and there, but we can think global and act local out of Lisbon.” Anthony Douglas, Hole19 November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  25. Startups enjoy major benefits from being located in Europe’s leading hubs, but there is still little interconnectivity between them SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech25 11% 70% 20% 69% No real differenceDisadvantages outweigh advantages 22% 71% Advantages outweigh disadvantages 9% 18% 8% 41% 54% 37% 46% Emerging links 8% Weak links 57% 46% Strong links 4% 7% AllFoundersInvestorsAllFoundersInvestors Importance of tech hubs and interconnectivity Q: Do you think it is important for a company's HQ to be located in a major European tech hub? Q: How would you describe the degree of interconnectivity between Europe's different tech hubs? Source: Slush & Atomico Survey “Apart from personal relationships that founders have with friends, there's no exchange going on at all. For example, people from London are not systematically coming to Berlin or Stockholm or wherever to exchange knowledge. At best they may pop in for a coffee when they happen to pass through but there is no structure. It is a huge responsibility that falls back to the VCs and the people that fund companies across the region because they have the key network and they are the link between the companies.” Florian Meissner, EyeEm November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  26. Sebastian Siemiatkowski, Klarna “Today, if you’re really talented and you reach out, you could instantly get quite good backing from mentoring and advice on money and so forth - and this did not exist ten years ago. That has definitely changed. It’s still harder if you’re in Poland; it’s easier if you’re in Berlin or in Stockholm.” In their own words SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech26 Christian Hernandez, White Star Capital “There are a whole set of European companies today that actually will produce significant wealth, which can then permeate back into the ecosystem as role models the people will aspire to follow. We will then see the kind of momentum that leads LPs to want to bet more actively in Europe and provide more supply and capital at the later stages where we’re still lacking.” Anthony Douglas, Hole19 “Lisbon’s changed, I’m considered one of the “old school” guys as I started before people even knew what the word start-up was in Lisbon in 2011/2012. Then Startup Lisboa brought the first wave of entrepreneurs together into one place. Two or three years later and Web Summit is coming to Lisbon, we’ve got Portuguese startups like Codacy actually winning the Web Summit, we’ve got companies like Talkdesk & Uniplaces raising huge rounds, etc. A lot of young people are actually seeking out advice from some of the "older" guys. We’re giving advice to the younger entrepreneurs, and even the older ones who are quitting their jobs to start their own companies - they’re not making the same mistakes that we made. I pride myself on that, as I made every single mistake, and giving some of this knowledge back to the community is really important for the ecosystem to thrive.” Florian Meissner, EyeEm “When I started I was completely wet behind my ears, and I dived into a very early stage of Berlin start-up. There simply weren’t a lot of people back then who you could look up to or ask for advice. That started to change shortly after I came back. There were a couple of people starting companies at the same time. Some failed, and some of us survived, but now there is a tight- knit community of founders that have emerged from that field and we're now very close friends. Some of us started investing on our own, and some of us actually still run companies but most of us are acting as mentors to others. This is not unique to Berlin. I think a number of cities in Europe have their own cohort” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  27. 4. Talent November 2015 Source: Achievement unlocked: 1.6m professional developers in Europe What’s next: address alarming gender imbalance #whatsnext4eutech
  28. European talent exists, you just have to know where to find it SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech28 50% Q: How would you rate the general availability of European engineering talent? Q: How would you rate the general quality of European engineering talent? 39% 20% Good pool of talent 40% 18% 10% Very good pool of talent 40% Severe lack of talent 0%1% 16% 18% 1% 15% 26% 31% 25% Lack of talent Adequate pool of talent Founders Investors All 10% 40% 11% Higher quality than other regions 42% 39% 7% Much higher quality than other regions 1% Much lower quality than other regions 0% 0% 4% Lower quality than other regions 4% On a par with other regions 3% 43% 46% 50% Investors AllFounders Availability and quality of talent in Europe Source: Slush & Atomico Survey •  57% of all respondents think there is good or very good availability of European engineering talent •  Founders are most positive, with 60% believing there is at least a good pool of talent •  The quality of talent that is available in Europe is perceived to be at least on a par with other regions and many believe it to be better •  Only 4% of all respondents think the European talent pool is lower quality than other regions November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  29. Europe’s key hubs are building a critical mass of developers… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech29 # of professional developers per hub and density of professional full-stack developers per country – data from Stack Overflow Developer Insights 3.50.2 Full-stack developers per ,000 people 38,194 Moscow 22,944 Istanbul 9,990 Lisbon 27,333 Madrid 71,497 London 40,538 Paris 15,915 Berlin 11,346 Stockholm9,586 Oslo Source: London, Europe’s largest developer hub, has 71,497 professional developers compared to 83,262 in San Francisco According to Stack Overflow Developer Insights, there are 1.6M professional developers in Europe today November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  30. …and, importantly, a large pool of mobile developers SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech30 # of professional mobile developers per country – data from Stack Overflow Developer Insights Source: “There is a huge opportunity for entrepreneurs focusing on mobile technology. Europe's population of mobile developers is now larger than that of the USA - in fact, European startups have access to more than 50,000 mobile specialists than their American counterparts” Dimitar Stanimiroff, Stack Overflow Developer Insights •  The UK has the largest professional mobile developer pool, but there are growing hubs of talent emerging across the whole region, including in places such as Poland and Turkey. •  The Nordic region is an emerging hub for mobile development within Europe, and is home to 9% of the region's mobile developers. Sweden has over 7,000 mobile developers; almost half of whom reside in Stockholm. 4,0474,1964,7395,2187,6257,7158,75210,40210,87914,49214,89817,74018,488 31,25132,525 Russia Spain Poland Turkey UnitedKingdom Europe UnitedStates Germany Italy France 237,437 186,602 Netherlands Ukraine Switzerland Austria Romania Belgium Sweden Professional mobile developers November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  31. Europe is also nurturing a strong talent pipeline for the future SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech31 +600.000 / y US 0.5m 1.1m Europe Europe 9.7m US 4.5m +5.2m Europe produces 2x more STEM grads per year than the US… …and the cumulative difference over 10 years is >5m grads STEM grads per year STEM grads over past ten years STEM = Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics Source: Eurostat “You’ve got some of the top universities in the world in Europe. You no longer have to go to Stanford or Harvard or MIT to get great engineering talent. You can now go to Imperial, Cambridge in the UK or ETH in Zurich or the Max Planck Institutes in Germany or École Polytechnique in France.” Brent Hoberman, Founders Forum November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  32. But tech entrepreneurship still has an alarming gender imbalance 11% 89% SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech32 Q: What is your gender? (founders only) “We’ve seen the share of female attendees at Slush grow from 5% to 25% in just a few years, but amongst founders the change is painfully slow.” Riku Mäkelä, Slush Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  33. Median annual base salary in US$ thousands There is a clear cost advantage to building a team from Europe 33 Sr SW Engineer x 2 SW Engineer x 3 UX Designer x 1 Data Analyst x 1 OperationsProduct 376 118121 1,078 334 Sales & MarketingFinance 85 Engineering 474 17 member team 752 110 1,477 10877 LondonSan Francisco SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech Note: The roles chosen are designed to represent the hypothetical team of an early-stage SaaS company, excluding an assumed technical founding team Source: Product Manager x 1 Operations Manager x 1 Office Manager x 1 Finance Manager x 1 Sales Director x 1 BusDev Manager x 1 Sales Associate x 1 Marketing Manager x 1 Customer Service x 2 The total base salary cost of a 17 member team is ~1.5x higher in San Francisco than in London, according to salary data from Glassdoor November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  34. Building a world-class leadership team in Europe is viable… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech34 50% 37% Disagree I don’t know Strongly agree 6% 4% Agree 2% Strongly disagree 36% 6% 1% 12% 44% 13% 7% 41% 2% 37% Investors All respondents Founders •  Of all respondents, 80% agree that it is possible to build a world-class leadership team in Europe •  Over a third of respondents strongly agree with the statement, with an even response rate from both founders and investors Statement: It is possible to find talent to build a world-class startup leadership team in Europe Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  35. …but it involves competing in a global war for top executive talent SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech35 Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews Sebastian Siemiatkowski, Klarna “The problem is I now need senior executives that have experience of working in a company that has grown from a couple of hundred million dollars in revenue to a couple of billion dollars in revenue. These types of people are rare in Sweden. It is hard to find senior executives to help grow from a small to a medium sized and then to a really huge international company and to encourage the talent to move here. I’m competing with PayPal now. I need to be able to hire the same people they hire.” Florian Meissner, EyeEm “The signs are there that the top global executive talent is ready to join European tech companies but it is not easy; it really takes a huge effort. If you are only looking at Berlin or London for the right people you are not thinking big enough. You have to think of the biggest fish in the world and then you need to try and poach them. That is the mindset you have to have. You should not be aiming to hire from the small business round the corner but the global leader in your field.” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  36. European countries are introducing programmes to attract overseas talent, but more can always be done to turn a trickle into a flow SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech36 Country Name of Programme Year Introduced Guidelines UK UK Tier 1 Entrepeneurship Visa 2008 3-Year Residency Permit (except for Prospective which is 6 months), Requirement of Maintenance varies Ireland Start-up Entrepeneur Programme 2010 2-Year Residency Permit, Renewable for 3 additional years, Requirement of €75,000 Italy Startup Law 2012 1-Year Residency Permit, Requirement of €50,000 Spain Ley de Emprendedores (Entrepeneur's Act) 2013 2-Year Residency Permit, Renewable for 3 additional years, Requirement of €75,000 Denmark Start-up Denmark 2015 2-Year Residency Permit, Renewable for 3 additional years, Requirement of €17,500 Netherlands Ambitious Entrepreneurship 2015 1-Year Residency Permit France French Tech Ticket 2015 Prize Money of €12,500 (Renewable at end of 6-month program), Residency Permit Fast-Track, Residency Permit of 6 years Source: Government websites, "I think in general, there are a lot of non-native founders in the UK. There are a lot of people who found companies and grow them and have particular risk tolerance who are also immigrants and I think there is a correlation. I think the immigration system in the UK has - up until now - been a competitive advantage. Eileen Burbridge, Sherry Coutu and Sean Park are all immigrants who have been welcomed and have driven innovation. Listening to the current immigration debate I worry that these benefits are at risk“ Brynne Herbert, MOVE Guides November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  37. In their own words SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech37 Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews Petri Järvilehto, Seriously “About half of our development team in Helsinki is from outside of Finland. It’s quite easy to recruit from within Europe, and especially in gaming there’s been a shift where you have people from other industries hopping over to gaming. It used to be the other way around: game developers had dreams of making movies one day, but today you have Oscar winners in gaming companies.” Anthony Douglas, Hole19 “One of the reasons why Lisbon is great is that we have access to great talent, particularly in design and development; we also have really talented engineers from the major technical universities, like the Superior Technical Institute here in Lisbon. We usually hire graduates straight out of the Institute, we work closely with those guys.” Ilkka Paananen, Supercell “With regards to talent, there’s still a bit of friction but even that is slowly getting better. In the gaming industry, many talented developers are a little older which means they have families. In this sense, Finland has a few big advantages such as the world’s best elementary school system that has gotten a lot of praise in global PISA studies in recent years. Many people want to raise their kids here because of that.” Dimitar Stanimiroff, Stack Overflow Developer Insights “For years it's been said that 'the European startup scene is up and coming'. Our technology has identified over 1.6m professional developers in the region, proving that startups now have access to a pool of technical talent that's even larger than the US. Forget up and coming, it's all happening now.” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  38. 5. Capital Flows November 2015 Source: Achievement unlocked: on track for $10B invested capital in 2015 What’s next: bridging the late-stage funding gap with European capital #whatsnext4eutech
  39. Capital is flooding into Europe Total # of rounds up 2.5x in three years… •  Total deal volume has more than doubled in Europe in the past five years •  2014 saw the record year for deal volume, but 2015 has seen a slowdown so far this year …and $ value growing rapidly •  Since 2014, Europe has seen increased late-stage funding contributing to significant $ amount growth in invested capital •  A large share of capital has been invested by non-European funds that have increasingly recognised Europe’s potential SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech39 Deal volume and value across Europe* 1,976 3,011 2,601 1,785 1,274 20132012 2015 YTD2011 2014 +33.2% 2015 YTD2012 2014 4.6 7.1 2013 4.8 +23.5% 9.4 3.8 2011 Source: CrunchBase, *Technology investments only. Excludes Israel. 2015 YTD based on 9M to September 2015 US$B invested# of deals November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  40. An explosion in seed rounds and strong capital flow into later stages Seed stage round counts exceed growth at other stages… …but $ amount growth in Series B and later SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech40 Deal volume and value across Europe by stage* 377 422 441 623 377 641 1,047 1,782 1,962 1,209 158 189 243 252 237 107 87 30 9 16 11 25 81 42 1,976 42 3,011 2014 2015 YTD2013 2,601 2012 1,785 39 1,274 2011 71 35 76 16 0.9 2.0 0.8 0.9 1.1 2012 0.4 4.6 7.1 0.7 1.4 0.5 3.8 1.0 0.7 2011 1.0 2.5 2014 2015 YTD 2.6 2013 9.4 1.8 4.8 0.6 1.0 0.3 0.7 1.8 0.6 0.6 0.6 1.8 0.6 0.3 0.6 0.2 0.2 1.2 Source: CrunchBase, *Technology investments only. Excludes Israel. 2015 YTD based on 9M to September 2015 Series C Series A Seed OtherSeries B Series D+ US$B invested# of deals November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  41. UK draws largest share of rounds and total capital deployed UK sees largest overall deal flow… …as well as largest share of invested capital SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech41 Deal volume and value in Top 5 countries in Europe* 180 158 277 408 832 638 510 764799 118 107107 164 125 131 192 207 135 154 570 2012 1.274 1.976 73 1.785 2015 YTD 3.011 2013 2014 2.601 2011 1.255 1.068 42 1.283 64 96 48 91 51 2013 4.8 2012 4.6 2015 YTD2014 7.1 9.4 2011 3.8 1.3 0.3 0.3 0.5 1.0 1.0 0.1 1.4 0.9 0.1 2.9 1.4 2.0 1.6 1.7 1.7 0.7 0.3 0.4 0.3 3.8 2.1 0.40.4 0.5 0.4 0.1 0.6 0.2 1.4 Note: Top 5 countries based on European countries with the largest sum of total invested capital in 2015 YTD Source: CrunchBase, *Technology investments only. Excludes Israel. 2015 YTD based on 9M to September 2015 United Kingdom Rest of EuropeFranceGermany NetherlandsSweden US$B invested# of deals November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  42. Europe’s top hubs grab growing share of invested capital SLUSH & ATOMICO | State of Technology in Europe42 Top 5 European hubs versus overall capital invested in Europe* •  Top 5 hubs represent an all-time-high share of total European funding at ~47% •  Both Top 5 investment hubs and rest of Europe growing annually in $ value invested •  Signs that a winner-takes-most dynamic is emerging at the geographic level, where the leading hubs capture a growing share of overall capital invested in the region Capital invested as % of total in Europe in period Note: Top 5 hubs based on European cities with the largest sum of total invested capital in 2015 YTD Source: CrunchBase, *Technology investments only. Excludes Israel. 2015 YTD based on 9M to September 2015 30.2% 46.8% 69.8% 53.2% 2015 YTD2011 Rest of Europe London + Stockholm + Berlin + Paris + Moscow November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  43. Europe is witnessing the rise of entrepreneur-led investing Founder-funder angel investment transactions per year1 # of startups funded by entrepreneur-led VCs per year2 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech43 Founder-funder transactions per year and # of European startups funded by entrepreneur-led VCs* Note 1: Unique investments into European companies by European angel investors that have previously founded and built their own European technology company. One round per investor per company included only. Excludes founders that have founded institutional VCs. Note 2: Number of European technology companies funded by entrepreneur-led European institutional VC funds. Includes any fund where at least one of the Founding Partners of the fund has previously founded and built a European technology company. Source: CrunchBase, *Technology investments only. Excludes Israel. 2015 YTD based on 9M to September 2015 173174 150 88 145 48 193 2014 2015 YTD201320122011 Projection for 2015 142 113 88 80 111 37 Projection for 2015 2013 2014 148 2015 YTD20122011 “It's easier to start a company than ever, but scaling to become a global winner is still very hard. We know what that feels like as an entrepreneur, and we learned a lot of lessons from scaling Skype about what to do and what not to do. Rather than trying to create one more successful company, we thought we could have more impact by helping an entire generation of European founders build the Skypes of tomorrow.” Niklas Zennström, Atomico # of startups# of deals November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  44. Europe’s leading hubs are building strong pools of angel investors SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech44 Active angel investors per city 5456748892 124130147153161168 196 250 270 325 383 420 Oslo Brussels Hamburg Copenhagen Munich Madrid Vienna Zurich Dublin Stockholm Berlin Barcelona London 2.125 Moscow Amsterdam Helsinki Paris Istanbul Angels per ’000 people 0,25 0,19 0,11 0,54 0,02 0,02 0,25 0,10 0,05 0,19 0,11 0,34 0,24 0,16 0,05 0,04 0,32 0,09 Source: Angel List, FiBAN Europe now has over 5,000 active angel investors resident in the region’s top hubs, according to Angel List “Successful entrepreneurs are now taking the time, sitting down with startups, mentoring them and many are acting as business angels. There's a whole shift of mentality amongst entrepreneurs with people thinking globally and wanting to create huge businesses. And now the angel money is definitely there to support them and there are a number of good mentors that can give proper advice, as well as seed capital. This just didn’t exist when we started Klarna ten years ago” Sebastian Siemiatkowski, Klarna November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  45. A new breed of institutional VC funds is rising in Europe SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech45 New institutional tech VC funds launched in Europe since 2011 with a minimum fund size of US$40m 40 6669 110120 140 166 200 385 Passion Capital SpeedInvest Hoxton Ventures83North Project A VenturesGlobal Founders Capital Lakestar Mosaic Ventures Felix Capital Year founded Location 2013 Luxembourg 2014 UK 2013 Germany 2015 UK 2015 UK 2012 Germany 2011 UK 2013 UK 2011 Austria Most recent fund size, US$m Source: Dow Jones VentureSource, Press releases November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  46. European and international corporates are increasingly active in Europe SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech46 Selected corporate investors with dedicated European tech VC focus Source: Company press releases Salesforce Ventures Announced: 2015 Fund size: $100M / year "There is so much incredible innovation happening in Europe today. Our $100 million commitment strengthens our mission to help startups grow and give back to their communities.” Google Ventures Announced : 2014 Fund size: $125M / year “We believe Europe’s startup scene has enormous potential. We’ve seen compelling new companies emerge from places like London, Paris, Berlin, the Nordic region and beyond —SoundCloud, Spotify, Supercell and many others.” IrisNext Announced : 2015 Fund size: $329M “The goal of this new fund, named IrisNext, is to become one of Europe’s leading venture capital funds through funding from major international groups of French, German and international origins, as well as from institutional investors” Deutsche Telekom (DTCP) Announced : 2014 Fund size: $275M “DTCP will support Deutsche Telekom’s strategy as an external innovation engine through investments in venture capital, with a special focus on Germany’s exciting and growing start-up scene.” Non-European European Supported by Iris Capital & Capnamic “The corporates are waking up to the idea of digital disruption and entrepreneurship in general. The corporates we talk to through Founders Intelligence want their employees to be more entrepreneurial and to work much more closely with entrepreneurs” Brent Hoberman, Founders Forum November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  47. Capital is more readily available in Europe… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech47 18% 8% "It is hard to raise capital" 18% 9% 58% 8% "It is the best time ever to raise capital" 47% 20% "Capital is more readily available today" 53% 22% "The capital environment is unchanged" "It is harder than ever to raise capital" 22% 3% 12% 2%1% Investors All Founders •  55% of entrepreneurs and 80% of investors believe that there’s more capital available than a few years ago •  Investors are noticeably more positive on the current situation of capital availability •  51% of founders that have previously started a company think capital is now more readily available versus 40% of first-time founders, suggesting repeat entrepreneurs may find it easier to raise rounds Q: How has the experience of raising capital in Europe changed? Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  48. …but Europe still lacks capital relative to the opportunity SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech48 VC funds in the US raised 5.4 times more capital than their European counterparts 82 28 2.9x USEurope 76.1 14.0 5.4x USEurope The US produces 2.9x more $B+ companies than Europe… …but US VCs raised 5.4x more capital than European VCs Companies surpassing $B+ milestone by geography, Q1/13-Q2/15 Funds raised by VCs by region, US$B, Q1/13-Q2/15 Source: Atomico, DowJones VentureSource November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  49. This lack of capital is most prominent at Series B & beyond… SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech49 VC funds raised in Europe and US, by investment stage Funds raised by VCs, 2010-2014, US$B ~5x 13.0 Multi-stage 46.8 10.0 Later-stage (Series B+) 42.3 1.8 24.3 ~14x ~3x Early-stage (Seed/Series A) USEurope •  The US produces 3x as many $B+ companies as Europe, but raises 5x as much capital •  The relative availability of capital varies significantly by stage. At the Series B stage and beyond there is a significant difference in terms of available capital (14x US vs Europe) relative to the number of companies reaching $B+ valuations •  As a result, there are relatively fewer local firms able to fund the increasing number of European winners on their path to global category leadership Source: Dow Jones VentureSource November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  50. …so leading US VCs are active in Europe and filling the funding gap SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech50 “While we don’t have an office in Europe we do have fourteen portfolio companies and every USV partner has at least two European portfolio companies. So we all travel to Europe regularly and we look at new investments.” Fred Wilson, Union Square Ventures VC Selected investments in Europe (SWE) (UK)(SWE) (GER) (UK)(GER) (SWE)(UK) (UK) (SWE) (GER)(SWE) Source: CrunchBase, (UK)(GER) (GER) November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  51. In their own words SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech51 Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews Petri Järvilehto, Seriously “It’s definitely a lot easier to build a global tech company than it was 6 or 7 years ago. Funding is the first thing that is just completely different to some years back. In Finland alone, you have several sources of pre-VC funding that enable you to get going, and then raising venture capital has become a lot more efficient as well.” Petteri Koponen, Lifeline Ventures “It absolutely has become easier to raise funds as an investor over the past five years. A good track record is crucial for a VC investor when she is fundraising; we can see a huge difference between now and four years ago when we were raising our first VC fund. Overall, there are more European VCs with a solid track record so it’s easier to raise funds.” Riccardo Zacconi, King “I think the investment landscape in Europe is dramatically different. There is much more money in the market than a few years ago, but also much more competition.” Ilkka Paananen, Supercell “I’d say that today it’s easier to raise capital. Mostly because all top-tier investors have already done at least their first investment into Northern Europe. So they’ve gone over that entry barrier, and it’s much easier after that.” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  52. 6. Europe’s Success Stories November 2015 Achievement unlocked: 10 $B+ companies in 2015, making a total of 35 since 2003 What’s next: companies valued in the tens and hundreds of billions #whatsnext4eutech
  53. More hugely successful companies are now coming from Europe SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech53 # of European $B+ companies founded since 2003, by year first surpassed $B+ milestone 2010 2012 2014 4 (+2) 35 (+10) 2015 YTD 1 (+1) 13 (+5) 2013 2 (+1) 2005 2011 25 (+12) 8 (+4) Source: Atomico, *2015 YTD is to 30 October 2015 Skype was the only $B+ company founded since 2003 from Europe until 2010 November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  54. Europe’s hall of fame: European $B+ companies founded since 2003 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech54 $B+ companies by country Source: Atomico UK 2015 (2010) 2011 (2007) 2014 (2007) 2013 (2003) 2015 (2007) 2015 (2010) 2015 (2011) 2015 (2009) 2015 (2009) 2014 (2007) Sweden 2005 (2003) 2014 (2009) 2011 (2006) 2014 (2003) Germany 2012 (2007) 2015 (2012) 2014 (2010) 2015 (2011) 2012 (2008) 2014 (2009) 2014 (2007) 2015 (2011) Russia 2013 (2007) 2012 (2006) 2013 (2005) 2014 (2007) France 2014 (2006) 2013 (2005) Netherlands 2014 (2006) Ireland 2012 (2004) Finland 2013 (2010) Denmark 2014 (2007) Key: Year reached $B+ (founding year) November 2015#whatsnext4eutech 2015 (2003) 2010 (2003)
  55. European companies are transforming a wide range of sectors SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech55 8 2 33 4 7 8 Financial Services GamingEnterprise Apps Retail Social & comms OtherMusic 8 27 EnterpriseConsumer $B+ companies by sector and customer focus Retail, financial services have produced most $B+ companies Consumer-focused companies dominate •  “Other” category consists of six different verticals •  All retail companies originate from large domestic markets (UK, GER), and 4 out of 7 are Rocket Internet-backed firms •  Europe’s $B+ companies are dominated by consumer- focused businesses, but Europe is also building a growing portfolio of enterprise success stories Source: Atomico $B+ companies by industry sector $B+ companies by primary customer focus November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  56. Europe is delivering the end product through exits SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech56 Operating status of $B+ companies founded since 2003 and total proceeds raised via IPOs European $B+ companies exit at same rate as other regions European tech companies outraising US companies at IPO Source: Atomico, CapitalIQ 49% 46% 42% 51% 54% 58% Exited Asia Europe North America Private 0.5 1.5 4.5 3.6 5.3 19.9 2.4 6.9 3.9 16.0 5.0 2.2 2011 20152012 2013 2014 Facebook IPO Europe US 29 18 24 41 24 $B+ companies by operating status IPO proceeds raised in US$bn by tech companies by region 100+ European tech IPOs since 2011, according to CapitalIQ November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  57. Europe’s challenge is to build the next generation of global winners SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech57 Share of global $B+ companies and categorization of $B+ companies founded since 2003 The US and China have produced larger companies… …and are home to all $10B+ companies founded since 2003 Source: Atomico 53% 63% 15% 9% 23% 22% 5%10% Share of market cap created by $B+ companies Share of $B+ companies globally Europe China US Rest of World 94 25 25 19 11 13 8 7 10 7 7 Rest of World 24 4 1 Europe 35 2 China 52 125 US $3-5B $5-10B $10-50B $50B+ $1-3B 3 November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  58. 7. The Future November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  59. Europe has laid the foundations for a bright future SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech59 Q: Are you more or less optimistic today about the future of European technology than 12 months ago? Very positive view shared by all respondent groups… …and the next generation is the most optimistic Source: Slush & Atomico Survey 8% 6% 39% 8% 32% Less More 55% 62% 53% 38% About the same AllInvestorsFounders 62% 35-44 18-2425-34 55% 75% 51% 45-54 51% 55+ Age group % of respondents more optimistic about the future than 12 months ago November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  60. Europe’s next generation will create even more success stories SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech60 European $B+ companies by year founded 8 15 11 1 2015-2017 ? ? 2006-2008 ? 2012-20142009-20112003-2005 Avg. time to $B+ (years) 6.3 4.6 3.0 ??? Source: Atomico 8.3 •  Over the past decade, companies have taken on average 5.7 years to first surpass the $B+ milestone •  Given this lag, companies founded since 2011 will only start to reach their potential in the coming years •  Europe’s “class” of 2011 onwards will produce even more global category leaders •  In short, the best is yet to come from the new generation of startups originating from Europe’s maturing tech hubs November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  61. Europe is already building and investing in the next generation of potential success stories SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech61 Methodology: total funding >$10M, most recent round since 1 Jan 2015, HQ in Europe, financing raised from one of the following: Accel Partners, Atomico, Balderton Capital, Creandum, Earlybird, Google Ventures, Index, Lakestar, Mosaic Ventures, Northzone Source: CrunchBase November 2015#whatsnext4eutech “Major cities in Europe have emerged as important tech hubs and I’m very excited about what the future holds. For example, London leads the way in terms of Fintech. In Stockholm, the success of Skype and Spotify have positively influenced many Swedish entrepreneurs. Rocket, in Germany, has become a source of execution-focused talent. And in Helsinki, incumbents like Nokia fed talent into Supercell and Rovio creating a leading hub for mobile gaming. The virtuous cycle is increasingly self perpetuating where the combination of top talent, strong exits and successful entrepreneurs re-investing in the ecosystem generates leading companies." Carolina Brochado, Atomico
  62. European VCs will need to keep pace with the scale of entrepreneurial ambition SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech62 Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews Christian Hernandez, White Star Capital “I think there is a disconnect between the intellectual output of Europe and the ability of funders to understand that intellectual output. The UK has one of the largest outputs of artificial intelligence and machine learning PhDs through Edinburgh, Imperial, UCL & Cambridge. And while we all run around saying that we're looking for AI Machine Learning startups, how many of us are actually deep enough to be able to go head-to-head with a CTO on Neural Networks? I'd say, half a dozen, if that, and that's across all of Europe. So we rely on our network of contacts and friends to help educate us, but if we're supposed to be betting on world-disrupting technology, how do we as investors become more adept at understanding what world- disrupting technology is? What a great challenge to have!” Florian Meissner, EyeEm “We don't have that kind of craziness yet. This moonshot idea of say building the next car, or sending people to the moon with rockets. But, I think this will evolve, because we just need a couple of really successful outcomes. People have got to dream bigger. It's a natural evolution of ambition levels, which are evolving on a daily basis.” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  63. The best time in history to be a European technology entrepreneur SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech63 36% 43% Strongly disagree I don’t know 17% 10% Disagree 11% 17% 12% 36% 3% 5% 14% 2% 3%2% 1% 27% Agree 46% 40% Strongly agree 27% 50%Founders Public sector Corporate employees Investors •  Founders and investors have the most positive view on the current situation: 50% of investors and 40% of founders agree strongly •  Repeat founders had a noticeably more positive view than first-time founders •  Employees of corporations and the public sector are positive, but not quite as much Statement: Now is the best time in history to be a technology entrepreneur in Europe Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  64. The state of European technology in one word SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech64 Inspiring Catchingup Expanding Note: includes clear 1-3 word combinations that answer the question, precise synonyms have been consolidated and typos corrected. Word cloud shows words with a frequency of 2 or more. Source: Slush & Atomico Survey Emerging Growing Promising Exciting Booming Fragmented Vibrant DiverseInteresting Innovative Changing Developing Good Bubble Rising Accelerating Scattered Up-and-coming Challenging Competitive Thriving Adolescent Amazing Aspiring Blossoming Boring Complex Conservative Enthusiastic ExplodingGreat Infancy OK Opportunistic Opportunity Potential Vital Average Awakening Awesome Boiling Burgeoning Calm Challenged Challenger Confident Copycat Creative Digitalization Dispersed Disruptive Driven Dull Early Falling behind Follower Heterogenous Improvable Improved International Intriguing Lagging Mature Nascent Old Over-hyped Possibility Reborn Renewing Runner up Shy Startup Striving Strong Struggling Teenager Undervalued Vivid Wannabe Q. What one word would you use to describe the state of European technology today? November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  65. In their own words SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech65 Source: Atomico & Slush Interviews Ilkka Paananen, Supercell “It is easier to build a global technology company from Europe than six or seven years ago for a number of reasons: it is easier to raise money, it is cheaper to build and operate products and services thanks to innovations like cloud platforms and it is easier to get global distribution thanks to app stores and the Internet. And, very importantly, there are role models these days, people who have successfully built globally successful companies, who inspire others to do the same. “In other words, the importance of geographic location has decreased significantly. And interestingly, we do have an advantage in Europe that has to do with geography. Europe is a fragmented home base with many languages, cultures, and small domestic markets. Because of this it seems to be more natural for Europeans to think global from day one. For example, no startup entrepreneur in Finland would ever build anything just for the local home market because it is simply so tiny. So we need to, and want to go global from day one. It feels natural for us. I don’t think it is the same for entrepreneurs who have larger home markets. “Over the next ten years there will be a lot more successful companies out of Europe. And I think that people will have stopped wondering about this rise of European tech, as it has become something of a norm. We won’t have the debates on European versus American technology entrepreneurship, and people will definitely have stopped questioning Europe’s role in global tech. I think people will take it for granted that all technology entrepreneurship is global by nature, including entrepreneurship in Europe.” November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  66. Final thoughts November 2015 Daniel Ek, Spotify “Being an entrepreneur is not for the faint-hearted. It’s an insane emotional rollercoaster. Even at this stage, people say “You’re done, you’ve done the hard years, now you can relax.” That’s not how it works, there are still days that are incredibly tough. I think that’s life if you’re an entrepreneur and you’re constantly not satisfied with the status quo.” #whatsnext4eutech
  67. Join the conversation November 2015 What’s next for European tech? #whatsnext4eutech @atomico @SlushHQ #whatsnext4eutech
  68. 8. Appendix November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  69. Survey respondents SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech69 n=844 Survey respondents by age Survey respondents by gender Survey respondents by occupation group Survey respondents by geography 55+ 6% 45-54 18% 18-24 25-34 5% 35-44 33% 38% 1% Female 19% 80% Male Prefer not to say 5% Founder 35% Student 5% Startup employee Investor 16% 15% OtherCorporate Public Sector 18% 4% Rest of EuropeDACH 21.0% Nordics UK & Ireland 10.3% 15.9% 52.8% Source: Slush & Atomico Survey November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  70. Europe in context SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech70 Population: 1,252m GDP: $1.82 trillion Internet users: 233m Smartphone users: 187m Population: 1,367m GDP: $9.20 trillion Internet users: 673m Smartphone users: 269m Population: 506m GDP: $17.97 trillion Internet users: 399m Smartphone users: 222m Source: World Bank, ITU, Eurostat, GSMA Intelligence Population: 321m GDP: $15.40 trillion Internet users: 279m Smartphone users: 176m November 2015#whatsnext4eutech
  71. Acknowledgements 71 SLUSH & ATOMICO | The State of European Tech •  Niklas Zennström •  Tom Wehmeier •  Shari Doherty •  Maxim Streletzki •  Sana Fathima •  Andrea Ringblom •  Carolina Brochado •  Riku Mäkelä •  Marianne Vikkula •  Andreas Saari •  Sami Hakkarainen •  Linn Henrichson •  Alan Mamedi, Truecaller •  Anthony Douglas, Hole19 •  Brent Hoberman, Founders Forum •  Brynne Herbert, MOVE Guides •  Christian Hernandez, White Star Capital •  Daniel Ek, Spotify •  Florian Meissner, EyeEm •  Ilkka Paananen, Supercell •  Nami Zarringhalam, Truecaller •  Petteri Koponen, Lifeline Ventures •  Petri Järvilehto, Seriously •  Riccardo Zacconi, King •  Sebastian Siemiatkowski, Klarna FOUNDERS & INVESTORS •  Gené McPherson, CrunchBase •  Cory Cox, CrunchBase •  Joe Wiggins, Glassdoor •  David Pashman, •  Nan Li, •  Natalia Radcliffe-Brine, Stack Overflow •  Dimitar Stanimiroff, Stack Overflow DATA PARTNERS November 2015#whatsnext4eutech