SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
What Animal Lovers Need to Know
                        About Devocalization
                             The family that bought Phoebe didn’t know her breeder had
                             her devocalized. Thanks to this cruel surgery, her voice is
                             permanently hoarse. She gags on food—and even water.
                             Meet Phoebe and other devocalized dogs:
                             Search Faces of Devocalization on www.youtube.com
                             Hear what animal experts say:
                             Search Unkindest Cut Devocalization on www.youtube.com

Sometimes dogs and cats must undergo vocal cord surgery to treat disease, like cancer,
or to correct a birth defect. But when performed for the sole purpose of suppressing the
animal’s voice—called devocalization—this practice is widely considered an act of
cruelty. Long banned throughout the UK and now in Massachusetts, devocalization
subjects animals to pain and stress along with many risks, some life-threatening.
Helpless to refuse this unnecessary surgery, they receive no benefit, not even the
assurance of a home: Devocalization is selfishly performed for convenience and profit,
often to facilitate a breeding business or a hobby involving dogs or cats.

                                              FAQs
Is devocalization the same as debarking or bark softening?
“Debarking” doesn’t accurately describe this surgery, which alters all vocalization, not just
barking. Some animals are left completely silent. It is also done to cats—who don’t bark!—
though less often than dogs. “Bark softening” is spin. It’s a meaningless term created to sanitize
an act of cruelty.

What does a devocalized animal sound like?
Devocalized voices are typically described as “disturbing.” These animals may sound:
      Raspy and hoarse, like they have laryngitis.
      Wheezy, like they have asthma.
      Shrill and screechy.
      Usually without vocal distinctions that communicate different meanings.
      Often accompanied by persistent coughing and/or gagging.
      Some animals are rendered completely mute.

Who would have a dog or cat devocalized and why?
      Breeders, when they or authorities don’t tolerate the sound of their many animals.
      Show dog exhibitors, to keep dogs quiet in transit between shows or in the ring.
      Sled dog racers, because dogs in a pack tend to vocalize more.
      Dog fighters and those who hoard or “collect” many animals, to hide their activities.
      Occasionally, selfish or uninformed pet owners, because this dangerous surgery is
       easier for them than responsible selection, care, training and housing of an animal.

How is devocalization done?
Vocal cord tissue is cut using one of two methods:
      Through a surgical incision in the neck (laryngotomy) OR
      By inserting instruments through the mouth.
      The veterinarian may use a scalpel, scissors, biopsy tools or even laser. The result
       is the same: Soft tissue is cut or otherwise altered, subjecting animals to surgical risks
       and potential complications that may compromise them for life or result in a terrible death.

                                              continued
Scar tissue blocked Stella’s airway after a breeder had her devocalized.
              Corrective surgery funded by her adopter saved this gentle Lab’s life,
                  but nothing could save her voice. Stella is permanently mute.

What are the risks of devocalization?
      All devocalization procedures carry risks, such as blood loss and infection.
      The risk of infection is greater for devocalization than other types of surgery due to
       the large number of bacteria in the oral cavity and throat.
      The potential for internal scarring is greater with the less invasive method,
       in which vocal cords are accessed through the mouth.

                                 Porter’s breeder had him devocalized, then didn’t want him.
                                 Massive scarring after his vocal cords were cut—through the
                                 oral cavity, the less invasive approach—put Porter at risk for
                                 heat stroke and aspiration pneumonia. Though his adopter paid
                                 for corrective surgery, Porter will never again bark or breathe
                                 normally. He’s the lucky one. Two devocalized kennel mates
                                 had to be euthanized. One died from aspiration pneumonia.

What is the danger of scarring in the throat?
Scar tissue blocking the airway may not be evident until years after the devocalization. The
animal then may:
      Struggle to breathe, particularly during exercise or in warm weather.
      Gag on food and water.
      Cough persistently.
      Die from choking, aspiration pneumonia or heat stroke.
      Be at greater risk during future medical procedures requiring anesthesia.
      Require corrective surgeries, with additional stress, pain and risks.

                         Demi, whose breeder had her devocalized, spent the first few
                         years of her life in a cage. She was spayed after being given to a
                         rescue group; scarring from the devocalization made it difficult to
                         keep her airway open during the procedure. Demi can’t bark at all,
                         only whine, and just a little exercise stresses her—results of vocal
                         cord surgery she didn’t need and was helpless to refuse.


Does the veterinarian’s skill or the instrument used remove risks?
Surgical risks and potential complications, such as airway obstruction, are present regardless of
the vet’s skill, level of experience or the instrument used (scalpel, scissors, biopsy tools or laser).

Is recovery from devocalization surgery painful?
Although most animals are anesthetized during the procedure, anyone who has undergone
throat surgery (or suffered strep throat!) can attest: Recovery is very painful. People can manage
their own pain with medication or other palliative measures. However, animals rely on the
goodwill and responsibility of their owners; not all dogs and cats receive proper post-operative
care or pain relief.
                                              continued
Lady was left at a shelter after being devocalized.
                               She was adopted—and given up again.

Does devocalization keep animals out of shelters?
      Shelter executives say no. They testified that devocalized animals are given up for
       the same reasons as any other.
      Cutting vocal cords to mask vocalization enables owners to ignore the underlying reason,
       typically boredom, loneliness or other distress. Allowing the animal’s distress to continue
       may lead to behaviors for which they are surrendered, such as biting and house-soiling.
      Some devocalized animals are given to shelters and rescue groups when they can’t be
       used for breeding, exhibition or sport—or sold.
      Devocalization may increase the risk of relinquishment or convenience euthanasia
       when an owner is unable or unwilling to pay for procedures to treat complications,
       which are common. Corrective surgery to remove scar tissue obstructing the airway is
       very expensive. Without it, the animal could die a premature and horrible death.



                           Snow was chained outside all day, barking her loneliness
                           and frustration. She was devocalized and then given up
                           anyway, relinquished to a rescue group.


Won’t seniors have to give up their pets if they can’t have them devocalized?
      Eldercare and senior housing professionals testified that owner infirmity and
       financial concerns, not the dog’s barking, are the reasons seniors surrender pets.
      With its high risk of complications, devocalization could further strain the finances
       of those on fixed incomes, resulting in relinquishment or euthanasia of the animal.
      Loneliness, boredom and distress are the top three reasons dogs bark tenaciously,
       according to Pat Miller, CDBC, CPDT, a certified dog behavior consultant and past
       president of the Association of Pet Dog Trainers. Seniors typically spend ample time
       with their pets, providing the companionship that reduces or eliminates attention-barking.
      Barking doesn’t hurt seniors, but biting does. The dog who can’t audibly and
       unambiguously bark a warning s/he’s about to bite is a danger to the owner and
       others. Seniors may not be able to hear or understand the muffled, indistinguishable
       sounds a devocalized dog makes. And experts say most people cannot interpret a dog’s
       or cat’s body language; who would imagine a wagging tail could mean “stay away”?
       Seniors with reduced vision or impaired cognition are even less able to recognize non-
       vocal signs of imminent attack.

What about spay/neuter—isn’t it more invasive than devocalization?
That’s a hollow argument made by those who profit from devocalization. Veterinarians and
shelter executives testified before the Massachusetts legislature that devocalization subjects
animals to serious risks but no benefit, not even a secure home. In contrast:
      Spay/neuter benefits animals by reducing the risk of certain cancers.
      Spay/neuter benefits society by reducing pet overpopulation.
      Spay/neuter reduces excessive vocalization triggered by hormonally driven
       excitement or aggression.
                                              continued
Isn’t devocalization important for good relationships with neighbors?
Access to devocalization discourages the responsible animal care essential for harmony
between neighbors. Even devocalized animals may jump on people, dig up the garden, or soil
the neighbor’s yard or public property. Unaltered animals, devocalized or not, may be aggressive
or produce unwanted litters that burden municipal pounds. These behaviors are prevented by
training, responsible care and supervision, not vocal cord surgery.

Isn’t devocalization a better option than electronic collars?
Neither is a good option. But while electronic collars can be dangerous, the risks of vocal cord
surgery—including airway obstruction, blood loss and adverse reaction to anesthesia—are far
greater. Collars are easily removed. Internal scarring, a common complication of devocalization
that can result in lifelong suffering or a terrible death, can only be removed with more surgery.

So what’s the alternative? Responsibility!
      Don’t keep groups of animals for breeding or sport, or get a pet predisposed to
       frequent vocalization, if you, a family member or neighbors do not tolerate the sound of
       barking or meowing.
      Spay/neuter at the appropriate age to reduce the hormone-driven aggression or
       excitement that may trigger frequent vocalization.
      Provide sufficient exercise, companionship and play: Bored, lonely dogs bark more!
      Rule out medical reasons for frequent vocalization, and consult a behavior specialist to
       resolve psychological or environmental triggers. Cutting vocal cords instead leaves the
       animal in distress, which s/he may then express in other ways, such as biting.

How many devocalized animals are there? Sadly, many more than you think.
In a year of canvassing for Logan’s Law, which prohibits canine and feline devocalization in
Massachusetts, members of the Coalition to Protect and Rescue Pets discovered hundreds of
devocalized dogs and some cats statewide. The scope of this cruelty is likely far greater but can’t
be quantified because those who order and those who perform devocalization rarely disclose it.
They’ve kept it under the radar with good reason—devocalization is a shameful practice.
And it’s easy to hide. Unlike tails and ears that have been surgically shortened (docked or
cropped) for so-called breed aesthetics, cut vocal cords are not visible. Most people assume the
dog or cat they hear rasping, wheezing, coughing and gagging has laryngitis or kennel cough.
Few imagine the cruel reality: The animal’s vocal cords were cut for an owner’s convenience.

© 2010, Coalition to Protect and Rescue Pets, CPRPets@aol.com
Veterinary information reviewed by Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association



           Use Your Voice to Protect Theirs. Ban Devocalization. TM




                                         IN MEMORY OF LOGAN
               This proud show dog’s breeder had him devocalized, then abandoned him
                when he stopped winning blue ribbons. Though he tried valiantly to bark
                    like his rescuer’s other dogs, Logan could only rasp and wheeze,
                                  cough and retch until the day he died.

More Related Content

Similar to Devocalization

What health problems do shih tzus have
What health problems do shih tzus haveWhat health problems do shih tzus have
What health problems do shih tzus havek60mall
 
How To Be A Veterinarian Essay
How To Be A Veterinarian EssayHow To Be A Veterinarian Essay
How To Be A Veterinarian EssayTammy Moncrief
 
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A Cat
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A CatAdvantages And Disadvantages Of A Cat
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A CatDeana Villanueva
 
What Is Over Grooming Behaviour
What Is Over Grooming BehaviourWhat Is Over Grooming Behaviour
What Is Over Grooming BehaviourSheri Elliott
 
Canin behaviour
Canin behaviourCanin behaviour
Canin behaviourAsif Pasha
 
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull TerrierGenetic Disorders American Pit Bull Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull TerrierLee McTaggart
 
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karki
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karkiImportant Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karki
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karkimanojj123
 
The vets 10 10-12 powerpoint
The vets 10 10-12 powerpointThe vets 10 10-12 powerpoint
The vets 10 10-12 powerpointJohn Pattyson
 
Diseas Disease Research Paper
Diseas Disease Research PaperDiseas Disease Research Paper
Diseas Disease Research PaperJasmine Culbreth
 
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire TerrierGenetic Disorders American Staffordshire Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire TerrierLee McTaggart
 
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical Lymphadenopathy
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical LymphadenopathyOutline Of The Workup Of Cervical Lymphadenopathy
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical LymphadenopathySarah Michalak
 
Ear Infection Research Paper
Ear Infection Research PaperEar Infection Research Paper
Ear Infection Research PaperMelissa Moore
 
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcome
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcomeVariety of disease in cats and how to overcome
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcomejos manik
 

Similar to Devocalization (20)

What health problems do shih tzus have
What health problems do shih tzus haveWhat health problems do shih tzus have
What health problems do shih tzus have
 
How To Be A Veterinarian Essay
How To Be A Veterinarian EssayHow To Be A Veterinarian Essay
How To Be A Veterinarian Essay
 
Animal Exploitation
Animal ExploitationAnimal Exploitation
Animal Exploitation
 
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A Cat
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A CatAdvantages And Disadvantages Of A Cat
Advantages And Disadvantages Of A Cat
 
Cats!
Cats!Cats!
Cats!
 
What Is Over Grooming Behaviour
What Is Over Grooming BehaviourWhat Is Over Grooming Behaviour
What Is Over Grooming Behaviour
 
Newfoundland Research Paper
Newfoundland Research PaperNewfoundland Research Paper
Newfoundland Research Paper
 
Canin behaviour
Canin behaviourCanin behaviour
Canin behaviour
 
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull TerrierGenetic Disorders American Pit Bull Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Pit Bull Terrier
 
Spleen
SpleenSpleen
Spleen
 
Essay On Lyssavirus
Essay On LyssavirusEssay On Lyssavirus
Essay On Lyssavirus
 
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karki
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karkiImportant Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karki
Important Zoonotic disease and its prevention and control By: Dr.Manoj karki
 
The vets 10 10-12 powerpoint
The vets 10 10-12 powerpointThe vets 10 10-12 powerpoint
The vets 10 10-12 powerpoint
 
Diseas Disease Research Paper
Diseas Disease Research PaperDiseas Disease Research Paper
Diseas Disease Research Paper
 
Mice Persuasive Essay
Mice Persuasive EssayMice Persuasive Essay
Mice Persuasive Essay
 
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire TerrierGenetic Disorders American Staffordshire Terrier
Genetic Disorders American Staffordshire Terrier
 
Canine ear
Canine earCanine ear
Canine ear
 
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical Lymphadenopathy
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical LymphadenopathyOutline Of The Workup Of Cervical Lymphadenopathy
Outline Of The Workup Of Cervical Lymphadenopathy
 
Ear Infection Research Paper
Ear Infection Research PaperEar Infection Research Paper
Ear Infection Research Paper
 
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcome
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcomeVariety of disease in cats and how to overcome
Variety of disease in cats and how to overcome
 

More from All Animal Rights

Christianity and vegetarianism
Christianity and vegetarianismChristianity and vegetarianism
Christianity and vegetarianismAll Animal Rights
 
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea Tacos
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea TacosKevin Nealon's Chickpea Tacos
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea TacosAll Animal Rights
 
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian Soup
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian SoupCasey Kasem's Vegetarian Soup
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian SoupAll Animal Rights
 
Boy George's Chick Pea Corruption
Boy George's Chick Pea CorruptionBoy George's Chick Pea Corruption
Boy George's Chick Pea CorruptionAll Animal Rights
 
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprises
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprisesFbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprises
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprisesAll Animal Rights
 
Ten tips on coping with pet loss
Ten tips on coping with pet lossTen tips on coping with pet loss
Ten tips on coping with pet lossAll Animal Rights
 
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestors
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestorsPermanent injunction against anti vivisection protestors
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestorsAll Animal Rights
 
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environment
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environmentA message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environment
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environmentAll Animal Rights
 
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat trade
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat tradeThai government announced steps to end the dog meat trade
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat tradeAll Animal Rights
 
Non animal technology the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...
Non animal technology   the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...Non animal technology   the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...
Non animal technology the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...All Animal Rights
 
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labs
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labsHow reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labs
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labsAll Animal Rights
 
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_report
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_reportGreenland expanding commercial whaling_report
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_reportAll Animal Rights
 
India's advances restrict animal experiments
India's advances restrict animal experimentsIndia's advances restrict animal experiments
India's advances restrict animal experimentsAll Animal Rights
 
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTSAll Animal Rights
 
Does animal testing help human medicine
Does animal testing help human medicineDoes animal testing help human medicine
Does animal testing help human medicineAll Animal Rights
 
Timeline of ifaw major victories from 1969 present
Timeline of  ifaw major victories from 1969   presentTimeline of  ifaw major victories from 1969   present
Timeline of ifaw major victories from 1969 presentAll Animal Rights
 

More from All Animal Rights (20)

Christianity and vegetarianism
Christianity and vegetarianismChristianity and vegetarianism
Christianity and vegetarianism
 
Quotes on Animal Rights
Quotes on Animal RightsQuotes on Animal Rights
Quotes on Animal Rights
 
Degu's
Degu'sDegu's
Degu's
 
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea Tacos
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea TacosKevin Nealon's Chickpea Tacos
Kevin Nealon's Chickpea Tacos
 
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian Soup
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian SoupCasey Kasem's Vegetarian Soup
Casey Kasem's Vegetarian Soup
 
Boy George's Chick Pea Corruption
Boy George's Chick Pea CorruptionBoy George's Chick Pea Corruption
Boy George's Chick Pea Corruption
 
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprises
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprisesFbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprises
Fbi repor tocongressterrorismonanimalenterprises
 
Is carrageenan unhealthy
Is carrageenan unhealthyIs carrageenan unhealthy
Is carrageenan unhealthy
 
156 wolf petitions
156 wolf petitions156 wolf petitions
156 wolf petitions
 
Ten tips on coping with pet loss
Ten tips on coping with pet lossTen tips on coping with pet loss
Ten tips on coping with pet loss
 
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestors
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestorsPermanent injunction against anti vivisection protestors
Permanent injunction against anti vivisection protestors
 
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environment
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environmentA message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environment
A message from nrdc green gifts that save the #environment
 
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat trade
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat tradeThai government announced steps to end the dog meat trade
Thai government announced steps to end the dog meat trade
 
Non animal technology the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...
Non animal technology   the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...Non animal technology   the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...
Non animal technology the future is amazing, and animal-free. #vivisection ...
 
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labs
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labsHow reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labs
How reliable are animal experiments? Exposing failure rates from animal labs
 
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_report
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_reportGreenland expanding commercial whaling_report
Greenland expanding commercial whaling_report
 
India's advances restrict animal experiments
India's advances restrict animal experimentsIndia's advances restrict animal experiments
India's advances restrict animal experiments
 
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS
50 DEADLY CONSEQUENCES OF LAB ANIMAL EXPERIMENTS
 
Does animal testing help human medicine
Does animal testing help human medicineDoes animal testing help human medicine
Does animal testing help human medicine
 
Timeline of ifaw major victories from 1969 present
Timeline of  ifaw major victories from 1969   presentTimeline of  ifaw major victories from 1969   present
Timeline of ifaw major victories from 1969 present
 

Devocalization

  • 1. What Animal Lovers Need to Know About Devocalization The family that bought Phoebe didn’t know her breeder had her devocalized. Thanks to this cruel surgery, her voice is permanently hoarse. She gags on food—and even water. Meet Phoebe and other devocalized dogs: Search Faces of Devocalization on www.youtube.com Hear what animal experts say: Search Unkindest Cut Devocalization on www.youtube.com Sometimes dogs and cats must undergo vocal cord surgery to treat disease, like cancer, or to correct a birth defect. But when performed for the sole purpose of suppressing the animal’s voice—called devocalization—this practice is widely considered an act of cruelty. Long banned throughout the UK and now in Massachusetts, devocalization subjects animals to pain and stress along with many risks, some life-threatening. Helpless to refuse this unnecessary surgery, they receive no benefit, not even the assurance of a home: Devocalization is selfishly performed for convenience and profit, often to facilitate a breeding business or a hobby involving dogs or cats. FAQs Is devocalization the same as debarking or bark softening? “Debarking” doesn’t accurately describe this surgery, which alters all vocalization, not just barking. Some animals are left completely silent. It is also done to cats—who don’t bark!— though less often than dogs. “Bark softening” is spin. It’s a meaningless term created to sanitize an act of cruelty. What does a devocalized animal sound like? Devocalized voices are typically described as “disturbing.” These animals may sound:  Raspy and hoarse, like they have laryngitis.  Wheezy, like they have asthma.  Shrill and screechy.  Usually without vocal distinctions that communicate different meanings.  Often accompanied by persistent coughing and/or gagging.  Some animals are rendered completely mute. Who would have a dog or cat devocalized and why?  Breeders, when they or authorities don’t tolerate the sound of their many animals.  Show dog exhibitors, to keep dogs quiet in transit between shows or in the ring.  Sled dog racers, because dogs in a pack tend to vocalize more.  Dog fighters and those who hoard or “collect” many animals, to hide their activities.  Occasionally, selfish or uninformed pet owners, because this dangerous surgery is easier for them than responsible selection, care, training and housing of an animal. How is devocalization done? Vocal cord tissue is cut using one of two methods:  Through a surgical incision in the neck (laryngotomy) OR  By inserting instruments through the mouth.  The veterinarian may use a scalpel, scissors, biopsy tools or even laser. The result is the same: Soft tissue is cut or otherwise altered, subjecting animals to surgical risks and potential complications that may compromise them for life or result in a terrible death. continued
  • 2. Scar tissue blocked Stella’s airway after a breeder had her devocalized. Corrective surgery funded by her adopter saved this gentle Lab’s life, but nothing could save her voice. Stella is permanently mute. What are the risks of devocalization?  All devocalization procedures carry risks, such as blood loss and infection.  The risk of infection is greater for devocalization than other types of surgery due to the large number of bacteria in the oral cavity and throat.  The potential for internal scarring is greater with the less invasive method, in which vocal cords are accessed through the mouth. Porter’s breeder had him devocalized, then didn’t want him. Massive scarring after his vocal cords were cut—through the oral cavity, the less invasive approach—put Porter at risk for heat stroke and aspiration pneumonia. Though his adopter paid for corrective surgery, Porter will never again bark or breathe normally. He’s the lucky one. Two devocalized kennel mates had to be euthanized. One died from aspiration pneumonia. What is the danger of scarring in the throat? Scar tissue blocking the airway may not be evident until years after the devocalization. The animal then may:  Struggle to breathe, particularly during exercise or in warm weather.  Gag on food and water.  Cough persistently.  Die from choking, aspiration pneumonia or heat stroke.  Be at greater risk during future medical procedures requiring anesthesia.  Require corrective surgeries, with additional stress, pain and risks. Demi, whose breeder had her devocalized, spent the first few years of her life in a cage. She was spayed after being given to a rescue group; scarring from the devocalization made it difficult to keep her airway open during the procedure. Demi can’t bark at all, only whine, and just a little exercise stresses her—results of vocal cord surgery she didn’t need and was helpless to refuse. Does the veterinarian’s skill or the instrument used remove risks? Surgical risks and potential complications, such as airway obstruction, are present regardless of the vet’s skill, level of experience or the instrument used (scalpel, scissors, biopsy tools or laser). Is recovery from devocalization surgery painful? Although most animals are anesthetized during the procedure, anyone who has undergone throat surgery (or suffered strep throat!) can attest: Recovery is very painful. People can manage their own pain with medication or other palliative measures. However, animals rely on the goodwill and responsibility of their owners; not all dogs and cats receive proper post-operative care or pain relief. continued
  • 3. Lady was left at a shelter after being devocalized. She was adopted—and given up again. Does devocalization keep animals out of shelters?  Shelter executives say no. They testified that devocalized animals are given up for the same reasons as any other.  Cutting vocal cords to mask vocalization enables owners to ignore the underlying reason, typically boredom, loneliness or other distress. Allowing the animal’s distress to continue may lead to behaviors for which they are surrendered, such as biting and house-soiling.  Some devocalized animals are given to shelters and rescue groups when they can’t be used for breeding, exhibition or sport—or sold.  Devocalization may increase the risk of relinquishment or convenience euthanasia when an owner is unable or unwilling to pay for procedures to treat complications, which are common. Corrective surgery to remove scar tissue obstructing the airway is very expensive. Without it, the animal could die a premature and horrible death. Snow was chained outside all day, barking her loneliness and frustration. She was devocalized and then given up anyway, relinquished to a rescue group. Won’t seniors have to give up their pets if they can’t have them devocalized?  Eldercare and senior housing professionals testified that owner infirmity and financial concerns, not the dog’s barking, are the reasons seniors surrender pets.  With its high risk of complications, devocalization could further strain the finances of those on fixed incomes, resulting in relinquishment or euthanasia of the animal.  Loneliness, boredom and distress are the top three reasons dogs bark tenaciously, according to Pat Miller, CDBC, CPDT, a certified dog behavior consultant and past president of the Association of Pet Dog Trainers. Seniors typically spend ample time with their pets, providing the companionship that reduces or eliminates attention-barking.  Barking doesn’t hurt seniors, but biting does. The dog who can’t audibly and unambiguously bark a warning s/he’s about to bite is a danger to the owner and others. Seniors may not be able to hear or understand the muffled, indistinguishable sounds a devocalized dog makes. And experts say most people cannot interpret a dog’s or cat’s body language; who would imagine a wagging tail could mean “stay away”? Seniors with reduced vision or impaired cognition are even less able to recognize non- vocal signs of imminent attack. What about spay/neuter—isn’t it more invasive than devocalization? That’s a hollow argument made by those who profit from devocalization. Veterinarians and shelter executives testified before the Massachusetts legislature that devocalization subjects animals to serious risks but no benefit, not even a secure home. In contrast:  Spay/neuter benefits animals by reducing the risk of certain cancers.  Spay/neuter benefits society by reducing pet overpopulation.  Spay/neuter reduces excessive vocalization triggered by hormonally driven excitement or aggression. continued
  • 4. Isn’t devocalization important for good relationships with neighbors? Access to devocalization discourages the responsible animal care essential for harmony between neighbors. Even devocalized animals may jump on people, dig up the garden, or soil the neighbor’s yard or public property. Unaltered animals, devocalized or not, may be aggressive or produce unwanted litters that burden municipal pounds. These behaviors are prevented by training, responsible care and supervision, not vocal cord surgery. Isn’t devocalization a better option than electronic collars? Neither is a good option. But while electronic collars can be dangerous, the risks of vocal cord surgery—including airway obstruction, blood loss and adverse reaction to anesthesia—are far greater. Collars are easily removed. Internal scarring, a common complication of devocalization that can result in lifelong suffering or a terrible death, can only be removed with more surgery. So what’s the alternative? Responsibility!  Don’t keep groups of animals for breeding or sport, or get a pet predisposed to frequent vocalization, if you, a family member or neighbors do not tolerate the sound of barking or meowing.  Spay/neuter at the appropriate age to reduce the hormone-driven aggression or excitement that may trigger frequent vocalization.  Provide sufficient exercise, companionship and play: Bored, lonely dogs bark more!  Rule out medical reasons for frequent vocalization, and consult a behavior specialist to resolve psychological or environmental triggers. Cutting vocal cords instead leaves the animal in distress, which s/he may then express in other ways, such as biting. How many devocalized animals are there? Sadly, many more than you think. In a year of canvassing for Logan’s Law, which prohibits canine and feline devocalization in Massachusetts, members of the Coalition to Protect and Rescue Pets discovered hundreds of devocalized dogs and some cats statewide. The scope of this cruelty is likely far greater but can’t be quantified because those who order and those who perform devocalization rarely disclose it. They’ve kept it under the radar with good reason—devocalization is a shameful practice. And it’s easy to hide. Unlike tails and ears that have been surgically shortened (docked or cropped) for so-called breed aesthetics, cut vocal cords are not visible. Most people assume the dog or cat they hear rasping, wheezing, coughing and gagging has laryngitis or kennel cough. Few imagine the cruel reality: The animal’s vocal cords were cut for an owner’s convenience. © 2010, Coalition to Protect and Rescue Pets, CPRPets@aol.com Veterinary information reviewed by Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association Use Your Voice to Protect Theirs. Ban Devocalization. TM IN MEMORY OF LOGAN This proud show dog’s breeder had him devocalized, then abandoned him when he stopped winning blue ribbons. Though he tried valiantly to bark like his rescuer’s other dogs, Logan could only rasp and wheeze, cough and retch until the day he died.