Shirly Ronen - Agile defect management - Functional Defects versus Regression Defects


Published on

Published in: Technology
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Shirly Ronen - Agile defect management - Functional Defects versus Regression Defects

  1. 1. Agile Defect managementFunctional defects vs Regression defects Shirly Ronen-Harel Oct 2010 shirly@agilesparks.com
  2. 2. An example of an agile bug management by an agile team/s
  3. 3. Life cycle principles • Defects management is one of Highly important process to manage efficiently and effectively. • Managing and resolving defects in a timely and efficient manner. • Outstanding defects can hold up the release of functionality to the business. • Defect should be related to functionality – not to a module. • Finding Defects Early. • Quality in – fixing and testing early.
  4. 4. Identify two types of defectsFunctional Defect :• Related to a specific user story and found during testing a specific user story . – A fault (Defect) will be traced to this user story . – In this case the fault (Defect) at the moment detected, is already in the iteration backlog , waiting for a decision.Regression defect :• Regression fault : a fault that was found during regression tests with no specific user story related or when a specific user story related is already delivered and close. – In this case it will be an independent regression fault (regression defect) – In this case fault (regression defect) will be added to the backlog as an item with priority and decision , unless it was fixed on the spot when detected.
  5. 5. Functional Defect• Development process: – A defect is a user story child. – It is born from a task testing or user story acceptance, regression, sanity testing
  6. 6. User story Task Task in Defect testing Defect Epic User story User story User story Acceptance tests - scenarios Defect Defect
  7. 7. Managing functional defects During the iteration : • Peering testers with developers; functional Defects are fixed immediately. • For every functional defect detected there should be a decision on fix or approved as open. • In case of ‘check-in’ to a branch fails – defect should be immediately fixed. • No additional code is integrated in cases of failed integration into a branch till the defects are fixed. • Defects fix are high priority against continue to code for a new functionality. • After the team creates a build the team performs sanity tests : Sanity defects – should be fixed immediately. • Code integrated Defects should not be left to the hardening phase. • End of iteration target – zero functional defects (either fixed or approved as open by PO for example : minor bugs). • As a result of acceptance tests, all defects decisions should be closed.
  8. 8. User story Task Fix immediately Task in Defect Test again before testing commit/integration Defect
  9. 9. What is done: User story PO decides: Defect Approve as open Fix before done Fix immediatelyA user story cannot be Done unless all of its bugs are fixed orapproved as open.
  10. 10. • Functional defects are fixed according to User story priority. • And not according to the defects priority between themselves. • Our goal is to finish user stories functionality first. User story User story User story priority 1 priority 2 priority 3 Defect Defect Defect Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1First fixed Defect Defect approve as Priority 2 open
  11. 11. Managing Regression defects Should be added to the sprint/ product backlog and prioritized as part of a backlog item. User story 1 User story 2 Regression defect 3 Regression defect 4 User story 5 Regression defect 6 User story 7 User story 8
  12. 12. Defects work flow – regression & customer related: Regression defect detected at customer Reproduced in our site site priority Product/ Regression defect not release reproduced or reproduced backlog as requirements Iteration backlog Regression defect during Customer lab iteration Version release development Production