SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 30
Download to read offline
Brito et al.                                             Investment, Dynamic Consistency and the Sectoral Regulator's Objective




         Investment, Dynamic Consistency and the Sectoral
                       Regulator's Objective
                     Duarte Brito                                                     Pedro Pereira
                  FCT-UNL and Cefage                                                       Adc
                 dmmcbrito@gmail.com                                           pedro.br.pereira@gmail.com

                                                      João Vareda
                                                      AdC and IST
                                              joao.vareda@concorrencia.pt


BIOGRAPHIES

Duarte Brito received his doctorate in economics from the Universidade Nova de Lisboa in 2001 and has been an assistant
professor at Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia, UNL since 2002. He is research fellow of the CEFAGE-UE and has
published one monograph and a dozen papers in international economics journals His main research interest is industrial
organization and he has been awarded several prizes and grants.

Pedro Pereira is a Senior Economist at the Portuguese Competition Authority. Pereira holds a doctorate from the University
of California, San Diego. He published on journals including Regional Science and Urban Economics, International Journal
of Industrial Organization, Information Economics and Policy, Southern Economic Journal, Review of Industrial
Organization.

João Vareda received his doctorate in Economics from the Universidade Nova de Lisboa in 2008. Presently, he works at the
Portuguese Competition Authority. His main research interests are Telecommunications Regulation and Competition Policy
and he has been awarded several prizes and grants. He recently published in the International Journal of Industrial
Organization, Information Economics and Policy, The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy and Telecommunications
Policy.




ABSTRACT
We explore the separation of powers between the legislative and the executive branch of government as a way of overcoming
the dynamic consistency problem of regulatory policy towards investment. We model the industry as a regulated duopoly.
The incumbent is a vertically integrated firm that owns a wholesale unit and a retail unit. The entrant only owns a retail unit.
Either retail unit needs access to the input produced by the wholesale unit to operate. The regulator is unable to commit to a
policy and the legislator sets the regulator's objective function. We derive general conditions under which, having the
legislator distort the regulator's objective function away from social welfare, allows implementing socially desirable
investment.

Keywords
Investment, Dynamic Consistency, Regulator's Objective




Proceedings of the 5th ACORN-REDECOM Conference, Lima, May 19-20th, 2011                                                       229
-31.#43(.-
   ; :.;F ?24B9.A21 6;1B@A?62@ 6;0B:/2;A@ .?2 ?2B6?21 A :.82 9.?42 6;C2@A:2;A@ )56@
6:=962@ A5.A A52 ?24B9.A?F =960F :B@A /.9.;02 A52 0;I60A6;4 4.9@ 3 ?21B06;4 A52 6;0B:
/2;A@J :.?82A =D2? ;.:29F ; A52 D592@.92 :.?82A .;1 46C6;4 6;0B:/2;A@ 6;02;A6C2@ A
6;C2@A ; A52? D?1@ ?24B9.A?F =960F :B@A A?.12 O @A.A60 .;1 1F;.:60 2N062;0F
   )56@ A?.12 O :.F 42;2?.A2 . 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: )52 ?24B9.A6; 3 .002@@
=?602@ 6@ .; 6:=?A.;A .?2. D52?2 A56@ :.F 00B? 23?2 6;C2@A:2;A 6A 6@ @06.99F =A6:.9
A @2A . 5645 .002@@ =?602 A =?:A2 6;C2@A:2;A D2C2? .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ :.12 6A 6@
@06.99F =A6:.9 A @2A . 9D .002@@ =?602 A =?:A2 0:=2A6A6; 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A )56@
1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: .O20A@ 6;C2@A:2;A ;24.A6C29F )52 6;0B:/2;A .;A606=.A2@ A5.A
6A D699 /2 2E=?=?6.A21 3?: A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA .;1 ?21B02@ 6;C2@A:2;A
   3 A52 ?24B9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . =960F A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 0.; /2 C2?
0:2 D2C2? AF=60.99F 6A 6@ ;9F 32.@6/92 3? A52 ?24B9.A? A 0::6A 3? . =960F 3? @5?A
=2?61@ D5692 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092 6; A52@2 6;1B@A?62@ 0.; /2 C2?F 9;4
   ;A52? =@@6/92 @9BA6; A A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 0;@6@A@ 3 16@A?A6;4 A52
?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F 3?: @06.9 D293.?2 6; . 3.@56; A5.A 2;@B?2@ A5.A 6A@
=A6:.9 =960F .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ A52 @.:2 .@ A52 ;2 3 . ?24B9.A? ./92 A 0::6A A
. =960F /23?2 6;C2@A:2;A )56@ ?2B6?2@ AD 0;16A6;@ 6?@A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2
3B;0A6; :B@A /2 @2A /F . A56?1 =.?AF (20;1 A52 A56?1 =.?AF :B@A /2 6::B;2 A A52
1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: .A 92.@A 3? A52 =2?61 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092
   ; :.;F 9246@9.AB?2@ A52@2 AD 0;16A6;@ .?2 =A2;A6.99F 3B9H9921      6?@A B@B.99F A52
@2=.?.A6; 3 =D2?@ /2AD22; A52 9246@9.A6C2 .;1 A52 2E20BA6C2 /?.;05 3 4C2?;:2;A 6:=962@
A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 2;.0A@ A52 9.D A5.A 4C2?;@ @20A?.9 ?24B9.A6; .;1 6; =.?A60B9.? 12H;2@
A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; )52; A52 ?24B9.A? 0.??62@ BA 6A@ :.;1.A2 /F ;.:29F
@2AA6;4 A52 .002@@ =?602 A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ D592@.92 @2?C602@ (20;1 A52 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6;
=?02@@ A.82@ :B05 9;42? A5.; A52 ?24B9.A?F 1206@6; =?02@@ )56@ 46C2@ A52 9246@9.A? A52
05.;02 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F 3? . 9;42? =2?61 A5.; A52 ?24B9.A? .;1 =2?5.=@
3? . =2?61 9;42? A5.; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092
   ; A56@ .?A6092 D2 2E=9?2 A52 @2=.?.A6; 3 =D2?@ /2AD22; A52 9246@9.A6C2 .;1 A52 2E20
BA6C2 /?.;05 3 A52 4C2?;:2;A .@ . D.F 3 C2?0:6;4 A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3
?24B9.A?F =960F AD.?1@ 6;C2@A:2;A ,2 12?6C2 42;2?.9 6;AB6A6C2 .;1 2.@F A 05208 0;
16A6;@ B;12? D5605 5.C6;4 A52 9246@9.A? 16@A?A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .99D@
6;0?2.@6;4 A52 ?.;42 3 =.?.:2A2? C.9B2@ 3? D5605 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 @06.99F 12@6?./92
6;C2@A:2;A   )52@2 42;2?.9 0;16A6;@ 2;0:=.@@ C.?6B@ :12@ 3 0:=2A6A6; AF=2@ 3
6;C2@A:2;A .;1 3?:@ 3 ?24B9.A6; .;1 .:B;A A ( A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6;0?2.@6;4
D6A5 A52 .002@@ =?602 .;1 (( A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 120?2.@6;4 D6A5 A52 .002@@ =?602
   ,2 :129 A52 6;1B@A?F .@ . ?24B9.A21 1B=9F )52 6;0B:/2;A 6@ . C2?A60.99F 6;A24?.A21
H?: A5.A D;@ . D592@.92? .;1 . ?2A.692? )52 2;A?.;A D;@ . ?2A.692? 6A52? ?2A.692? ;221@
.002@@ A A52 6;=BA =?1B021 /F A52 D592@.92? A =2?.A2 ,2 ?232? A A52 =?602 3 A52 6;=BA
.@ A52   6?@A A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6;
3? ( 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@      (( A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA .;1 ((( A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA )52@2
D2645A@ 12=2;1 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; D5605 6@ /@2?C21 /F A52 ?24B9.A?
(20;1 A52 6;0B:/2;A :.82@ 6A@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; )52 6;C2@A:2;A :.F 26A52? 6;0?2.@2
A52 B.96AF 3 A52 ?2A.69 @2?C602@ ? ?21B02 :.?46;.9 0@A@ )56?1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52
.002@@ =?602 B?A5 A52 2;A?.;A 120612@ D52A52? A 2;A2? A52 6;1B@A?F )52 A6:6;4 3 A52
4.:2 ?2I20A@ A52 .@@B:=A6;@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . 9246@9.A6C2 =960F D52?2.@
A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F
   ,2 ?232? A A52 .002@@ =?602 A5.A :.E6:6G2@ @06.9 D293.?2 46C2; A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@
:.12 6A@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .@ A52 #  .002@@ =?602
   3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 5.@ :?2 D2645A A5.; A52 H?:@J =?HA@ 6; A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2
3B;0A6; A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 /29D A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29  9D .002@@ =?602
6:=962@ . 9D :.?46;.9 0@A 3? A52 2;A?.;A .;1 . 9D D592@.92 :.?46; 3? A52 6;0B:/2;A
/A5 3 D5605 92.1 A 9D ?2A.69 =?602@ A52?2/F 6;0?2.@6;4 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 120?2.@6;4
A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA (6:69.?9F 63 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 5.@ :?2 D2645A A5.; 0;@B:2?
@B?=9B@ .;1 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29
   )52 .002@@ =?602 5.@ AD ==@6;4 2O20A@ ; D293.?2 6?@A . 56452? .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2
6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 46C2; A52 .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@
6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A D5605 6@ =@6A6C2 (20;1 . 56452? .002@@ =?602 92.1@ A 56452? ?2A.69
=?602@ D5605 6@ ;24.A6C2 ,52; 05@6;4 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6;
A52 9246@9.A? 5.@ A A?.12 O A52@2 AD 2O20A@
   3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99
=.?A62@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2
6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2 0;16A6;@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ A .C61 A52 9D .002@@
=?602 A5.A DB91 2:2?42 B;12? ; 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 3 A52
B=4?.121 ;2AD?8 .A A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A A.82@ 6;A2?:216.A2 C.9B2@
A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A
.;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2
06?0B:@A.;02@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 H?@A
/2@A 92C29     #D A52 A5?2.A 3 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A 2;B45
A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A )52 ?24B9.A? .9@ 5.@ A ?2D.?1 A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 5645 .002@@
=?602 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 2;02 6;C2@A:2;A 0:2@ .A A52 2E=2;@2 3 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?2A.69
:.?82A 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@
3 .99 =.?A62@ /A5 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2 06?0B:@A.;02@ A52
6;0B:/2;A 12@ ;A 6;C2@A .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 .A A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 ;
A56@ 0.@2 A52 9246@9.A? 05@2@ ;A A 16@A?A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =?232?2;02@ /20.B@2 26A52? A52
16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A ;202@@.?F A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 2E02@@6C29F 5645 ? 6A 6@
@6:=9F 6:=@@6/92 3? A52 ?24B9.A? A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A
      ,2 .9@ 0;@612? A5?22 2EA2;@6;@ 3 A52 /.@60 :129 6?@A D2 .;.9FG2 A52 0.@2 3 C2?
6;C2@A:2;A D5605 :.F 00B? D52; 6;C2@A:2;A 5.@ 6;0:=92A2 @=699C2?@ ; A56@ 0;A2EA 63
A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 =960F 6@ A 46C2 ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A
A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A (20;1 D2 .;.9FG2 A52 0.@2 D52?2 A52 9246@
9.A? 0.;;A @2A D2645A@ 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; *;12? A52@2
06?0B:@A.;02@ A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 =960F .0562C2@ . 9D2? D293.?2 92C29 .;1 6;C2@A:2;A
;9F 00B?@ 3? @:.992? C.9B2@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A @6;02 A52 16@A?A6;@ ?2B6?21 A 6;1B02
6;C2@A:2;A .?2 56452? )56?1 D2 16@0B@@ A52 0.@2 3 ?2A.69 =?602 ?24B9.A6; 99 3 B? ?2@B9A@
.9@ 591 6; A56@ 0;A2EA
      )52 ?2:.6;12? 3 A52 .?A6092 6@ ?4.;6G21 .@ 399D@ ; @20A6;
D2 ?2C62D A52 96A2?.AB?2
; @20A6; 
 D2 =?2@2;A A52 :129 ; @20A6;  D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 2B696/?6B: 3 A52 4.:2
; @20A6;  D2 .;.9FG2 A5?22 2EA2;@6;@ A A52 :129 6;.99F 6; (20A6;  D2 16@0B@@ A52
=960F 6:=960.A6;@ .;1 0;09B12



        (3$1 341$ $5($6
      )52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3 ?24B9.A?F =960F AD.?1@ 6;C2@A:2;A D.@ 16@0B@@21
/F !2CF .;1 (=6992? 
 .;1 #2D/2?F                        6; 42;2?.9 A2?:@ .;1 /F ?6A 2A .9
 
       .;@ .;1      6;4  
 ?.728 .;1 'P992?   .;1 +.?21.  
                    D6A5 . 30B@ ;
.002@@ ?24B9.A6; 
 +.?21.  
          @5D@ A5.A A52 9D2? A52 ?24B9.A?J@ 0::6A:2;A 0.=.06AF
A52 9D2? A52 6;C2@A:2;A 3 . ;2AD?8 =2?.A? D699 /2 /A5 ; 0@A ?21B0A6; .;1 ;
B.96AF B=4?.12@ ?.728 .;1 'P992?   H;1 A5.A D52?2.@ .002@@ ?24B9.A6; 6@ B;.O20A21
/F 2;A?.;A@J 6;C2@A:2;A .002@@ ?24B9.A6; :.82@ 2;A?F 2.@62? A52 56452? A52 92C29 3 A52
6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;3?.@A?B0AB?2 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 00?16;4 A A52@2 .BA5?@ A56@ @B442@A@ A5.A A52
  

      (22 BA5?62   3? . 16@0B@@6; ./BA A52 ?24B9.A?@ 6;./696AF A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F
?24B9.A?F 2;C6?;:2;A 6; B?=2 5.@ . 0::6A:2;A =?/92: D5605 ?21B02@ 6;0B:/2;A@J
6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A ?6A 2A .9          
    .;.9FG2 63 AD =.?A .002@@ A.?6O@ @9C2 A52 1F;.:60
0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3 A52 ?24B9.A6; 3 ;2D ;2AD?8@ .;1 @5D A5.A 63 A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A
0::6A A . =960F 6A 0.; 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A ;9F D52; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D .;1 A52
2;A?.;A :.82@ 9.?42 =.F:2;A@ A A52 6;0B:/2;A .;@ .;1                    6;4  
 @5D A5.A D52;
6;C2@A:2;A ?2AB?;@ .?2 B;02?A.6; .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A .; .002@@ =?602
D293.?2 6;0?2.@2@ 63 A52 ?24B9.A? 0::6A@ A . ?24B9.A?F :?.A?6B:
       (2C2?.9 .?A6092@ .;.9FG2 A52 612. 3 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F
3?: @06.9 D293.?2 A 0:=2;@.A2 3? @:2 @?A 3 :.?82A 6:=2?320A6; +429@.;4  

.?4B2@ A5.A 63 . ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F @3A ?24B9.A6; :.F
=?C612 /2AA2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6;02;A6C2@ A5.; A645A ?24B9.A6; D52?2 A645A ?24B9.A6; ?232?@
A . 9D ?24B9.A21 .002@@ =?602          ?:@A?;4 .;1 +6082?@ 
 .?4B2 A5.A .9A5B45 A52
1.;42? 3 ?24B9.A?F 0.=AB?2 :645A .?4B2 .4.6;@A 6;1B@A?F ?62;A21 ?24B9.A?@ @:2 124?22
3 6;1B@A?F ?62;A.A6; :645A 2;5.;02 A52 0?216/696AF 3 0::6A:2;A A .99D .; .12B.A2
?2AB?; ; 6;C2@A:2;A  $A52? @AB162@ D5605 0;C2F A52 612. 3 A52 2E6@A2;02 3 .; =A6
:.9 =@6A6C2 124?22 3 6;1B@A?F ?62;A.A6; 6; A52 =?2@2;02 3 A52? :.?82A 6:=2?320A6;@
6;09B12 52 
          2 64B26?21 2A .9       
    ?@@:.; .;1 29=:.;  
               (.9.;A
 
 (93              (=6992? 
     .;1 (=B9/2? .;1 2@.;8 
          )52?2 .?2 .9@ @AB162@
3? 6;@A.;02 /F ?6193@@;               !F;@  
 .;1 #2C2; .;1 '992?                    A5.A =?
=@2 6; A52 0;A2EA 3 :2?42?@ . 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ @A.;1.?1 A /2 B@21 @A?.A2460.99F /F A52
0:=2A6A6; .BA5?6A62@ .@ . :2.;@ 3 B9A6:.A29F .0562C6;4 4?2.A2? @06.9 D293.?2
       C.;@ 2A .9       .;1 !2C6;2 .;1 '608:.;   .;.9FG2 =?/92:@ @6:69.? A B?@
/BA 6; A52 0;A2EA 3 =.?A60B9.? :129@             )52 H?@A .?A6092 =?=@2@ .@ . @9BA6; A A52
B;12? 6;C2@A:2;A /F . :;=96@A ?2@B9A6;4 3?: A52 ?24B9.A?J@ 6;./696AF A 0::6A A5.A
A52 4C2?;:2;A 05@2@ . =.?A60B9.? AF=2 3 ?24B9.A? =? 6;1B@A?F ? .;A6 6;1B@A?F C2?
. =2?61 9;42? A5.; A52 2920A?.9 0F092
)52 .BA5?@ @5D A5.A D52; CA2?@ .?2 D299
6;3?:21 .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ ?2A.69 =?602@ . =? 6;1B@A?F ?24B9.A? :.F 6;1B02 H?@A /2@A
6;C2@A:2;A )52 @20;1 .?A6092 .;.9FG2@ A52 B;12? 6;C2@A:2;A =?/92: 6; A52 0;A2EA 3
. 1F;.:60 ?29.A6;@56= /2AD22; . ?24B9.A? .;1 . ?24B9.A21 :;=96@A D52?2 A52 3?:2?
   
       2@92F .;1 .A2
A2@A . :129 D52?2 ?24B9.A?@ A5.A .?2 16?20A9F 2920A21 /F A52 CA2?@ .?2 =?
0;@B:2? )52F @5D A5.A 6; A52 *( =?602@ .?2 9D2? 6; A5@2 @A.A2@ A5.A 2920A A526? ?24B9.A? A5.; 6; A5@2
D52?2 A52 ?24B9.A? 6@ .==6;A21 /F =96A606.;@ )52F .9@ @5D A5.A 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 56452? 6; @A.A2@ A5.A
.==6;A A52 ?24B9.A?
)56@ @9BA6; 399D@ A52 =?=@.9 /F '4O 
 D5605 0;@6@A@ ; . @20;1 /2@A 0::6A:2;A :205
.;6@: 6; D5605 A52 =?606;4 1206@6; 6@ 12924.A21 A .; 6;12=2;12;A ?24B9.A? D5@2 =?232?2;02@ 1 ;A
;202@@.?69F 06;0612 D6A5 A5@2 3 A52 4C2?;:2;A
6@ B;./92 A 0::6A )52F .@@B:2 A5.A A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A /@2?C2 D52A52? 6;C2@A:2;A
5.@ A.82; =9.02 /BA 0.; /@2?C2 A52 H?:J@ AA.9 0@A@       )52F @5D A5.A . =? 6;1B@A?F
?24B9.A? 0.; C2?0:2 A52 ?.A052A 2O20A $B? .?A6092 42;2?.96G2@ A52@2 ?2@B9A@ A . /?.12?
0;A2EA D5605 2;0:=.@@ C.?6B@ :12@ 3 0:=2A6A6; AF=2@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 3?:@
3 ?24B9.A6; ; .116A6; D2 .99D A52 9246@9.A? A @2A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6;
0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6;



       .#$+

        -5(1.-,$-3
     ;@612? . ?24B9.A21 1B=9F A5.A 6;09B12@ 3B? =9.F2?@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A52 2;A?.;A
A52 ?24B9.A? .;1 A52 9246@9.A? )52  H?:  6@ C2?A60.99F 6;A24?.A21 .;1 D;@
. /AA92;208 6;=BA .;1 0.; 6;C2@A )52  H?:  ;9F =2?.A2@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A
.;1 5.@ A /BF .002@@ A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208 6;=BA ,2 ?232? A A52 =?602 3 A52
/AA92;208 6;=BA .@   .;1 12;A2 6A /F    ,2 6;12E H?:@ D6A5 @B/@0?6=A   
 
)52   @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 )52  05@2@ A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2
3B;0A6;
     )52 4.:2 5.@ 3B? @A.42@ D5605 B;391 .@ 399D@ ; @A.42  A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52
D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; ; @A.42
A52 6;0B:/2;A 120612@ D52A52? A
6;C2@A ; @A.42 
 A52 @20A?.9 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ; @A.42  A52 2;A?.;A 120612@
63 6A 2;A2?@ A52 :.?82A ? ;A 3A2?D.?1@ A52 H?:@ =9.F @:2 :.?82A 4.:2
     ) 822= A52 :129 .@ 42;2?.9 .@ =@@6/92 D2 1 ;A :129 2E=9606A9F A52 :.?82A 4.:2
;@A2.1 D2 .@@B:2 A5.A A52 :.?82A 4.:2 5.@ . B;6B2 2B696/?6B: F62916;4 ?21B021 3?:
=?HA 3B;0A6;@ D6A5 ?2@=20A A D5605 D2 :.82 .@@B:=A6;@ 16?20A9F !.A2? 6; @20A6;@ 
 
.;1  D2 D699 =?C612 2E.:=92@ 3 @=206H0 :.?82A 4.:2@ A5.A :22A B? .@@B:=A6;@
     99 ?292C.;A 6;3?:.A6; /20:2@ 0::; 8;D92142 .@ A52 4.:2 B;391@


        (1,2
     A :645A /2 B@23B9 A A56;8 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208 6;=BA .@ . ;2AD?8 2 4 .
A2920::B;60.A6;@ ;2AD?8 .; 2920A?606AF ;2AD?8 ? . ?.69D.F ;2AD?8         A 0@A  ;


         A52 6;0B:/2;A 0.; :.82 .; 6;C2@A:2;A D5605 26A52? B=4?.12@ A52 ;2AD?8 ?
12=9F@ . ;2D .;1 :?2 .1C.;021 ;2AD?8 9@ 3? A52 @.82 3 0;0?2A2;2@@ 6A :645A /2
B@23B9 A A56;8 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A .@ 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 B.96AF 3 ?2A.69 @2?C602@ D2C2? .99
3 B? ?2@B9A@ .9@ .==9F 63 6;@A2.1 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 120?2.@2@ A52 :.?46;.9 0@A 3 ?2A.69
@2?C602@ ,2 D699 B@2 @B=2?@0?6=A   
  A 12;A2 D52A52? A52?2 D.@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ;A
?2@=20A6C29F
                              
         2;A2 /F                 . =.?.:2A2? A5.A :2.@B?2@ A52 B.96AF 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208
                                                                 
6;=BA 46C2;  %.?.:2A2?                                              A.82@ C.9B2 
 63    .;1 C.9B2                                                               ; 

                               63   
                                               
         2;A2 /F                     
                       A52 4?@@ =?HA 3 H?:   
                                                           3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F .;1 A52
6;1B@A?F 6@ . :;=9F A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 4?@@ =?HA 6@                                                                                                                   3 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F .;1 A52
                                                                                                                                 
6;1B@A?F 6@ . 1B=9F H?: J@ 4?@@ =?HA 6@                                                                              



                $3.1 + $4+ 3.1
         )52 ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F 6 2 A .; .002@@ =?602 2;02
6A :.82@ 6A@ 05602 .3A2? /@2?C6;4 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .@ 6; ?6A 2A .9
  

                                                   
         2;A2 /F                    
                       A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6@
#                  3 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6@ #                                                                      
                                                                                                                                       
       


         (06.9 D293.?2 6@

                                                                                                                                                                         
                                                           
                           
                                  
                                      


3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F @06.9 D293.?2 6@ '
#
3 A52 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F
@06.9 D293.?2 6@ '                        
                                                
       
                                                                     
                                                                       
                                                                               
                                                                                   
                          
                                                                                                               
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                           
       
                                                                                                                                                   #              
                                                                                                                                                                        
       


         )52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ . D2645A21 @B: 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 H?:@J
=?HA@
                                                                                                                                                                                 
                                   
 
                    
                                   
                                  
                                             
                         

                         
D52?2              .;1      .?2 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA .;1 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ ?2@=20A6C29F
                                                                              
D6A5
!2A                                  
                     #A2 A5.A                           
 
        
                                                                                                                                                            
       
                                                                                                                                                                                              
                                                                                                                                                                                                    
   

                                                                                                                                                                     
         )52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 A :.E6:6G2                                                                                    
 
               
                   @B/720A A A52 6;0B:
/2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A
                                                                                                              
                                                                                                          
               
                                                                                       
     
         6C2; B? .@@B:=A6;@ ./BA =.FO@ 6;A?1B021 6; @20A6;
A52?2 6@ ; ;221 A 46C2 . D2645A 56452?
A5.;       A A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA )52 9246@9.A? 0.; /A.6; . @6:69.? 2O20A /F .17B@A6;4 A52 D2645A@ A A52 A52?
=.?A62@J@ =.FO@
$(2+ 3.1
          *;9682 A52 ?24B9.A? A52 9246@9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6; =2?5.=@ /20.B@2
A52 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6; =?02@@ A.82@ 9;42? A5.; A52 ?24B9.A?F 1206@6; =?02@@ .;1 9;4
2;B45 3? A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092  2;02 A52 9246@9.A? :.82@ 6A@ 05602 /23?2 6;C2@A:2;A
          ; .116A6; A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ D2645A@ 12=2;16;4 ; D52A52? A52?2 D.@ 6;C2@A:2;A ?
;A )56@ .@@B:=A6; 6@ 7B@A6H./92 /20.B@2 A52 ?24B9.A? ;9F 05@2@ A52 .002@@ =?602 .3A2?
/@2?C6;4 D52A52? A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@ 6;C2@A21 ? ;A D2C2? 6A ?2B6?2@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A?
6@ ./92 A D?6A2 0:=92E 9.D@ ; @20A6;  D2 0;@612? .9A2?;.A6C2 .@@B:=A6;@
                                                                                                                                          
          )52 9246@9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ A52 ;2A @06.9 D293.?2                                                              
               


               224,/3(.-2 !.43  8.:2
          )5?B45BA A52 ?2:.6;12? 3 A52 .?A6092 D2 :.82 A52 399D6;4 .@@B:=A6;@ ./BA =.F
O@


                                                                                                                                                                     
                     )52?2 6@ .;                      ;           
        @B05 A5.A                   
                    
 63 .;1 ;9F 63
! )52?2 6@ .;                            ;                
           @B05 A5.A               
         
 63 .;1 ;9F 63                                         
                                                                 
                     # B;0A6;@                              
         .;1 #               .?2 0;A6;BB@9F 16O2?2;A6./92 6;                                 
                                                                                                                                                                       3?
                            
.99            ;        
       

              B;0A6;@ '                       .;1 '
.?2 6;0?2.@6;4 6;
? .99
6@ 6;0?2.@6;4 6;             .;1                  
                   


                                                                                                                 
 
 ? .99
#             6@ 120?2.@6;4 6;         
                                                                                             .;1 #                   
       
                                                                                                                                    #

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02Adane Nega
 
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)Vera Leonik-Shilyaeva
 
Lecture 13 environment management system
Lecture 13 environment management systemLecture 13 environment management system
Lecture 13 environment management systemAdane Nega
 
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar conf
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar confDown sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar conf
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar confAdane Nega
 
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007Adane Nega
 
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2adrianfleming1
 
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyes
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyesLecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyes
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyesAdane Nega
 
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)Vera Leonik-Shilyaeva
 
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)ACORN-REDECOM
 
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cotton
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cottonMercerization physical andchemical changes in cotton
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cottonAdane Nega
 
HCS trial - Summary & Results
HCS trial - Summary & ResultsHCS trial - Summary & Results
HCS trial - Summary & Resultstheheart.org
 
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigo
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigoInnovations in dyeing of cotton with indigo
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigoAdane Nega
 
Strategies to building a winning business
Strategies to building a winning businessStrategies to building a winning business
Strategies to building a winning businessAbel Mukwevho
 
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from corn
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from cornEco friendly synthetic fibre from corn
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from cornAdane Nega
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
 
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02
Kvic presentatio nnew 19.12.02
 
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)
Российская индустрия экспортной разработки программного обеспечения (pdf)
 
Lecture 13 environment management system
Lecture 13 environment management systemLecture 13 environment management system
Lecture 13 environment management system
 
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar conf
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar confDown sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar conf
Down sized khadi tech., bhuneshwar conf
 
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007
Khadi status future vision sept 20, 2007
 
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2
Save Time, Money and Hair with ManageCO2
 
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyes
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyesLecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyes
Lecture 6 dyeing of cotton with vat and sulphur dyes
 
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...
Can vertical separation reduce non price discrimination and increase welfare ...
 
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)
Машиностроение: Тенденции и Прогнозы (2011)
 
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)
Broadband economic impact in Brazil - Hildebrando Rodrigues (2011)
 
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cotton
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cottonMercerization physical andchemical changes in cotton
Mercerization physical andchemical changes in cotton
 
HCS trial - Summary & Results
HCS trial - Summary & ResultsHCS trial - Summary & Results
HCS trial - Summary & Results
 
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigo
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigoInnovations in dyeing of cotton with indigo
Innovations in dyeing of cotton with indigo
 
Strategies to building a winning business
Strategies to building a winning businessStrategies to building a winning business
Strategies to building a winning business
 
SIEMENS (Belarus)
SIEMENS (Belarus)SIEMENS (Belarus)
SIEMENS (Belarus)
 
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from corn
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from cornEco friendly synthetic fibre from corn
Eco friendly synthetic fibre from corn
 

More from ACORN-REDECOM

The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...
The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...
The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...ACORN-REDECOM
 
The role of social networks on regulation in the
The role of social networks on regulation in theThe role of social networks on regulation in the
The role of social networks on regulation in theACORN-REDECOM
 
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...ACORN-REDECOM
 
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Universal service a new definition james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...
Universal service a new definition   james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...Universal service a new definition   james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...
Universal service a new definition james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...ACORN-REDECOM
 
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação marta de campos ...
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação   marta de campos ...Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação   marta de campos ...
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação marta de campos ...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector mart...
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector   mart...Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector   mart...
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector mart...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...ACORN-REDECOM
 
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...ACORN-REDECOM
 
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico beatriz elen...
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico   beatriz elen...La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico   beatriz elen...
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico beatriz elen...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú liliana ru...
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú   liliana ru...Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú   liliana ru...
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú liliana ru...ACORN-REDECOM
 
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...ACORN-REDECOM
 

More from ACORN-REDECOM (20)

The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...
The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...
The role of social networks on regulation in the telecommunication industry t...
 
The role of social networks on regulation in the
The role of social networks on regulation in theThe role of social networks on regulation in the
The role of social networks on regulation in the
 
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
Restricted mobility or restricted competition fixed mobile convergence and un...
 
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...
De la tiza al ratón. escenarios de enseñanza en la formación de periodistas d...
 
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...
Comparing the impact of decline in leased line prices in india and indonesia ...
 
Universal service a new definition james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...
Universal service a new definition   james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...Universal service a new definition   james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...
Universal service a new definition james alleman, paul rappoport, aniruddha...
 
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...
Una alternativa hacia las ngn en las américas redes de banda ancha inalámbric...
 
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...
The new economics of ict the regulatory implications of post neoclassical eco...
 
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação marta de campos ...
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação   marta de campos ...Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação   marta de campos ...
Tecnologia de informação e comunicação aplicada à educação marta de campos ...
 
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector mart...
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector   mart...Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector   mart...
Regulation and innovation in the argentinean telecommunications sector mart...
 
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...
Reforma legislativa de la televisión ante el futuro digital en chile ¿hacia l...
 
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...
Promoción de la salud sexual y reproductiva y prevención del vihsida en jóven...
 
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...
Políticas y marco normativo orientados al acceso universal y la expansión de ...
 
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...
Only a few roads lead to rome the regulation of entry and broadband performan...
 
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...
O paradoxo da internet regulada a desregulação dos serviços de valor adiciona...
 
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico beatriz elen...
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico   beatriz elen...La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico   beatriz elen...
La infografía digital género periodístico y recurso pedagógico beatriz elen...
 
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...
Inclusión y cohesión social de las políticas públicas vinculadas con las tics...
 
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...
Inclusión digital estudio comparado de políticas públicas de colombia y de br...
 
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú liliana ru...
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú   liliana ru...Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú   liliana ru...
Impacto de la telefonía celular en zonas rurales pobres del perú liliana ru...
 
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...
Factores socioeconómicos y tecnológicos que incidirán en la adopción de la te...
 

Investment, dynamic consistency and the sectoral regulator's objective - Duarte Brito (2011)

  • 1. Brito et al. Investment, Dynamic Consistency and the Sectoral Regulator's Objective Investment, Dynamic Consistency and the Sectoral Regulator's Objective Duarte Brito Pedro Pereira FCT-UNL and Cefage Adc dmmcbrito@gmail.com pedro.br.pereira@gmail.com João Vareda AdC and IST joao.vareda@concorrencia.pt BIOGRAPHIES Duarte Brito received his doctorate in economics from the Universidade Nova de Lisboa in 2001 and has been an assistant professor at Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia, UNL since 2002. He is research fellow of the CEFAGE-UE and has published one monograph and a dozen papers in international economics journals His main research interest is industrial organization and he has been awarded several prizes and grants. Pedro Pereira is a Senior Economist at the Portuguese Competition Authority. Pereira holds a doctorate from the University of California, San Diego. He published on journals including Regional Science and Urban Economics, International Journal of Industrial Organization, Information Economics and Policy, Southern Economic Journal, Review of Industrial Organization. João Vareda received his doctorate in Economics from the Universidade Nova de Lisboa in 2008. Presently, he works at the Portuguese Competition Authority. His main research interests are Telecommunications Regulation and Competition Policy and he has been awarded several prizes and grants. He recently published in the International Journal of Industrial Organization, Information Economics and Policy, The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy and Telecommunications Policy. ABSTRACT We explore the separation of powers between the legislative and the executive branch of government as a way of overcoming the dynamic consistency problem of regulatory policy towards investment. We model the industry as a regulated duopoly. The incumbent is a vertically integrated firm that owns a wholesale unit and a retail unit. The entrant only owns a retail unit. Either retail unit needs access to the input produced by the wholesale unit to operate. The regulator is unable to commit to a policy and the legislator sets the regulator's objective function. We derive general conditions under which, having the legislator distort the regulator's objective function away from social welfare, allows implementing socially desirable investment. Keywords Investment, Dynamic Consistency, Regulator's Objective Proceedings of the 5th ACORN-REDECOM Conference, Lima, May 19-20th, 2011 229
  • 2. -31.#43(.- ; :.;F ?24B9.A21 6;1B@A?62@ 6;0B:/2;A@ .?2 ?2B6?21 A :.82 9.?42 6;C2@A:2;A@ )56@ 6:=962@ A5.A A52 ?24B9.A?F =960F :B@A /.9.;02 A52 0;I60A6;4 4.9@ 3 ?21B06;4 A52 6;0B: /2;A@J :.?82A =D2? ;.:29F ; A52 D592@.92 :.?82A .;1 46C6;4 6;0B:/2;A@ 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A ; A52? D?1@ ?24B9.A?F =960F :B@A A?.12 O @A.A60 .;1 1F;.:60 2N062;0F )56@ A?.12 O :.F 42;2?.A2 . 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: )52 ?24B9.A6; 3 .002@@ =?602@ 6@ .; 6:=?A.;A .?2. D52?2 A56@ :.F 00B? 23?2 6;C2@A:2;A 6A 6@ @06.99F =A6:.9 A @2A . 5645 .002@@ =?602 A =?:A2 6;C2@A:2;A D2C2? .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ :.12 6A 6@ @06.99F =A6:.9 A @2A . 9D .002@@ =?602 A =?:A2 0:=2A6A6; 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A )56@ 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: .O20A@ 6;C2@A:2;A ;24.A6C29F )52 6;0B:/2;A .;A606=.A2@ A5.A 6A D699 /2 2E=?=?6.A21 3?: A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA .;1 ?21B02@ 6;C2@A:2;A 3 A52 ?24B9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . =960F A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 0.; /2 C2? 0:2 D2C2? AF=60.99F 6A 6@ ;9F 32.@6/92 3? A52 ?24B9.A? A 0::6A 3? . =960F 3? @5?A =2?61@ D5692 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092 6; A52@2 6;1B@A?62@ 0.; /2 C2?F 9;4 ;A52? =@@6/92 @9BA6; A A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 0;@6@A@ 3 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F 3?: @06.9 D293.?2 6; . 3.@56; A5.A 2;@B?2@ A5.A 6A@ =A6:.9 =960F .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ A52 @.:2 .@ A52 ;2 3 . ?24B9.A? ./92 A 0::6A A . =960F /23?2 6;C2@A:2;A )56@ ?2B6?2@ AD 0;16A6;@ 6?@A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; :B@A /2 @2A /F . A56?1 =.?AF (20;1 A52 A56?1 =.?AF :B@A /2 6::B;2 A A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: .A 92.@A 3? A52 =2?61 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092 ; :.;F 9246@9.AB?2@ A52@2 AD 0;16A6;@ .?2 =A2;A6.99F 3B9H9921 6?@A B@B.99F A52 @2=.?.A6; 3 =D2?@ /2AD22; A52 9246@9.A6C2 .;1 A52 2E20BA6C2 /?.;05 3 4C2?;:2;A 6:=962@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 2;.0A@ A52 9.D A5.A 4C2?;@ @20A?.9 ?24B9.A6; .;1 6; =.?A60B9.? 12H;2@ A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; )52; A52 ?24B9.A? 0.??62@ BA 6A@ :.;1.A2 /F ;.:29F @2AA6;4 A52 .002@@ =?602 A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ D592@.92 @2?C602@ (20;1 A52 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6; =?02@@ A.82@ :B05 9;42? A5.; A52 ?24B9.A?F 1206@6; =?02@@ )56@ 46C2@ A52 9246@9.A? A52 05.;02 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F 3? . 9;42? =2?61 A5.; A52 ?24B9.A? .;1 =2?5.=@ 3? . =2?61 9;42? A5.; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092 ; A56@ .?A6092 D2 2E=9?2 A52 @2=.?.A6; 3 =D2?@ /2AD22; A52 9246@9.A6C2 .;1 A52 2E20 BA6C2 /?.;05 3 A52 4C2?;:2;A .@ . D.F 3 C2?0:6;4 A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3 ?24B9.A?F =960F AD.?1@ 6;C2@A:2;A ,2 12?6C2 42;2?.9 6;AB6A6C2 .;1 2.@F A 05208 0; 16A6;@ B;12? D5605 5.C6;4 A52 9246@9.A? 16@A?A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .99D@ 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 ?.;42 3 =.?.:2A2? C.9B2@ 3? D5605 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 @06.99F 12@6?./92 6;C2@A:2;A )52@2 42;2?.9 0;16A6;@ 2;0:=.@@ C.?6B@ :12@ 3 0:=2A6A6; AF=2@ 3
  • 3.
  • 4. 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 3?:@ 3 ?24B9.A6; .;1 .:B;A A ( A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6;0?2.@6;4 D6A5 A52 .002@@ =?602 .;1 (( A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 120?2.@6;4 D6A5 A52 .002@@ =?602 ,2 :129 A52 6;1B@A?F .@ . ?24B9.A21 1B=9F )52 6;0B:/2;A 6@ . C2?A60.99F 6;A24?.A21 H?: A5.A D;@ . D592@.92? .;1 . ?2A.692? )52 2;A?.;A D;@ . ?2A.692? 6A52? ?2A.692? ;221@ .002@@ A A52 6;=BA =?1B021 /F A52 D592@.92? A =2?.A2 ,2 ?232? A A52 =?602 3 A52 6;=BA .@ A52 6?@A A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 3? ( 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ (( A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA .;1 ((( A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA )52@2 D2645A@ 12=2;1 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; D5605 6@ /@2?C21 /F A52 ?24B9.A? (20;1 A52 6;0B:/2;A :.82@ 6A@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; )52 6;C2@A:2;A :.F 26A52? 6;0?2.@2 A52 B.96AF 3 A52 ?2A.69 @2?C602@ ? ?21B02 :.?46;.9 0@A@ )56?1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 B?A5 A52 2;A?.;A 120612@ D52A52? A 2;A2? A52 6;1B@A?F )52 A6:6;4 3 A52 4.:2 ?2I20A@ A52 .@@B:=A6;@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . 9246@9.A6C2 =960F D52?2.@ A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F ,2 ?232? A A52 .002@@ =?602 A5.A :.E6:6G2@ @06.9 D293.?2 46C2; A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@ :.12 6A@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .@ A52 # .002@@ =?602 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 5.@ :?2 D2645A A5.; A52 H?:@J =?HA@ 6; A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 /29D A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 9D .002@@ =?602 6:=962@ . 9D :.?46;.9 0@A 3? A52 2;A?.;A .;1 . 9D D592@.92 :.?46; 3? A52 6;0B:/2;A /A5 3 D5605 92.1 A 9D ?2A.69 =?602@ A52?2/F 6;0?2.@6;4 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 120?2.@6;4 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA (6:69.?9F 63 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 5.@ :?2 D2645A A5.; 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 )52 .002@@ =?602 5.@ AD ==@6;4 2O20A@ ; D293.?2 6?@A . 56452? .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 46C2; A52 .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A D5605 6@ =@6A6C2 (20;1 . 56452? .002@@ =?602 92.1@ A 56452? ?2A.69 =?602@ D5605 6@ ;24.A6C2 ,52; 05@6;4 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 9246@9.A? 5.@ A A?.12 O A52@2 AD 2O20A@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99 =.?A62@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2 0;16A6;@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ A .C61 A52 9D .002@@ =?602 A5.A DB91 2:2?42 B;12? ; 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 3 A52 B=4?.121 ;2AD?8 .A A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A A.82@ 6;A2?:216.A2 C.9B2@ A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2 06?0B:@A.;02@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 H?@A
  • 5.
  • 6. /2@A 92C29 #D A52 A5?2.A 3 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A 2;B45 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A )52 ?24B9.A? .9@ 5.@ A ?2D.?1 A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 5645 .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 2;02 6;C2@A:2;A 0:2@ .A A52 2E=2;@2 3 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99 =.?A62@ /A5 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ; 6;C2@A:2;A *;12? A52@2 06?0B:@A.;02@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 12@ ;A 6;C2@A .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 .A A52 H?@A /2@A 92C29 ; A56@ 0.@2 A52 9246@9.A? 05@2@ ;A A 16@A?A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =?232?2;02@ /20.B@2 26A52? A52 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A ;202@@.?F A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 2E02@@6C29F 5645 ? 6A 6@ @6:=9F 6:=@@6/92 3? A52 ?24B9.A? A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A ,2 .9@ 0;@612? A5?22 2EA2;@6;@ 3 A52 /.@60 :129 6?@A D2 .;.9FG2 A52 0.@2 3 C2? 6;C2@A:2;A D5605 :.F 00B? D52; 6;C2@A:2;A 5.@ 6;0:=92A2 @=699C2?@ ; A56@ 0;A2EA 63 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 =960F 6@ A 46C2 ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A (20;1 D2 .;.9FG2 A52 0.@2 D52?2 A52 9246@ 9.A? 0.;;A @2A D2645A@ 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; *;12? A52@2 06?0B:@A.;02@ A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 =960F .0562C2@ . 9D2? D293.?2 92C29 .;1 6;C2@A:2;A ;9F 00B?@ 3? @:.992? C.9B2@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A @6;02 A52 16@A?A6;@ ?2B6?21 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 56452? )56?1 D2 16@0B@@ A52 0.@2 3 ?2A.69 =?602 ?24B9.A6; 99 3 B? ?2@B9A@ .9@ 591 6; A56@ 0;A2EA )52 ?2:.6;12? 3 A52 .?A6092 6@ ?4.;6G21 .@ 399D@ ; @20A6;
  • 7. D2 ?2C62D A52 96A2?.AB?2 ; @20A6; D2 =?2@2;A A52 :129 ; @20A6; D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 2B696/?6B: 3 A52 4.:2 ; @20A6; D2 .;.9FG2 A5?22 2EA2;@6;@ A A52 :129 6;.99F 6; (20A6; D2 16@0B@@ A52 =960F 6:=960.A6;@ .;1 0;09B12 (3$1 341$ $5($6 )52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3 ?24B9.A?F =960F AD.?1@ 6;C2@A:2;A D.@ 16@0B@@21 /F !2CF .;1 (=6992? .;1 #2D/2?F 6; 42;2?.9 A2?:@ .;1 /F ?6A 2A .9 .;@ .;1 6;4 ?.728 .;1 'P992? .;1 +.?21. D6A5 . 30B@ ; .002@@ ?24B9.A6; +.?21. @5D@ A5.A A52 9D2? A52 ?24B9.A?J@ 0::6A:2;A 0.=.06AF A52 9D2? A52 6;C2@A:2;A 3 . ;2AD?8 =2?.A? D699 /2 /A5 ; 0@A ?21B0A6; .;1 ; B.96AF B=4?.12@ ?.728 .;1 'P992? H;1 A5.A D52?2.@ .002@@ ?24B9.A6; 6@ B;.O20A21 /F 2;A?.;A@J 6;C2@A:2;A .002@@ ?24B9.A6; :.82@ 2;A?F 2.@62? A52 56452? A52 92C29 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;3?.@A?B0AB?2 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 00?16;4 A A52@2 .BA5?@ A56@ @B442@A@ A5.A A52 (22 BA5?62 3? . 16@0B@@6; ./BA A52 ?24B9.A?@ 6;./696AF A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F
  • 8.
  • 9. ?24B9.A?F 2;C6?;:2;A 6; B?=2 5.@ . 0::6A:2;A =?/92: D5605 ?21B02@ 6;0B:/2;A@J 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A ?6A 2A .9 .;.9FG2 63 AD =.?A .002@@ A.?6O@ @9C2 A52 1F;.:60 0;@6@A2;0F =?/92: 3 A52 ?24B9.A6; 3 ;2D ;2AD?8@ .;1 @5D A5.A 63 A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A 0::6A A . =960F 6A 0.; 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A ;9F D52; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D .;1 A52 2;A?.;A :.82@ 9.?42 =.F:2;A@ A A52 6;0B:/2;A .;@ .;1 6;4 @5D A5.A D52; 6;C2@A:2;A ?2AB?;@ .?2 B;02?A.6; .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A .; .002@@ =?602 D293.?2 6;0?2.@2@ 63 A52 ?24B9.A? 0::6A@ A . ?24B9.A?F :?.A?6B: (2C2?.9 .?A6092@ .;.9FG2 A52 612. 3 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F 3?: @06.9 D293.?2 A 0:=2;@.A2 3? @:2 @?A 3 :.?82A 6:=2?320A6; +429@.;4 .?4B2@ A5.A 63 . ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F @3A ?24B9.A6; :.F =?C612 /2AA2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6;02;A6C2@ A5.; A645A ?24B9.A6; D52?2 A645A ?24B9.A6; ?232?@ A . 9D ?24B9.A21 .002@@ =?602 ?:@A?;4 .;1 +6082?@ .?4B2 A5.A .9A5B45 A52 1.;42? 3 ?24B9.A?F 0.=AB?2 :645A .?4B2 .4.6;@A 6;1B@A?F ?62;A21 ?24B9.A?@ @:2 124?22 3 6;1B@A?F ?62;A.A6; :645A 2;5.;02 A52 0?216/696AF 3 0::6A:2;A A .99D .; .12B.A2 ?2AB?; ; 6;C2@A:2;A $A52? @AB162@ D5605 0;C2F A52 612. 3 A52 2E6@A2;02 3 .; =A6 :.9 =@6A6C2 124?22 3 6;1B@A?F ?62;A.A6; 6; A52 =?2@2;02 3 A52? :.?82A 6:=2?320A6;@ 6;09B12 52 2 64B26?21 2A .9 ?@@:.; .;1 29=:.; (.9.;A (93 (=6992? .;1 (=B9/2? .;1 2@.;8 )52?2 .?2 .9@ @AB162@ 3? 6;@A.;02 /F ?6193@@; !F;@ .;1 #2C2; .;1 '992? A5.A =? =@2 6; A52 0;A2EA 3 :2?42?@ . 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ @A.;1.?1 A /2 B@21 @A?.A2460.99F /F A52 0:=2A6A6; .BA5?6A62@ .@ . :2.;@ 3 B9A6:.A29F .0562C6;4 4?2.A2? @06.9 D293.?2 C.;@ 2A .9 .;1 !2C6;2 .;1 '608:.; .;.9FG2 =?/92:@ @6:69.? A B?@ /BA 6; A52 0;A2EA 3 =.?A60B9.? :129@ )52 H?@A .?A6092 =?=@2@ .@ . @9BA6; A A52 B;12? 6;C2@A:2;A /F . :;=96@A ?2@B9A6;4 3?: A52 ?24B9.A?J@ 6;./696AF A 0::6A A5.A A52 4C2?;:2;A 05@2@ . =.?A60B9.? AF=2 3 ?24B9.A? =? 6;1B@A?F ? .;A6 6;1B@A?F C2? . =2?61 9;42? A5.; A52 2920A?.9 0F092
  • 10. )52 .BA5?@ @5D A5.A D52; CA2?@ .?2 D299 6;3?:21 .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ ?2A.69 =?602@ . =? 6;1B@A?F ?24B9.A? :.F 6;1B02 H?@A /2@A 6;C2@A:2;A )52 @20;1 .?A6092 .;.9FG2@ A52 B;12? 6;C2@A:2;A =?/92: 6; A52 0;A2EA 3 . 1F;.:60 ?29.A6;@56= /2AD22; . ?24B9.A? .;1 . ?24B9.A21 :;=96@A D52?2 A52 3?:2? 2@92F .;1 .A2
  • 11. A2@A . :129 D52?2 ?24B9.A?@ A5.A .?2 16?20A9F 2920A21 /F A52 CA2?@ .?2 =? 0;@B:2? )52F @5D A5.A 6; A52 *( =?602@ .?2 9D2? 6; A5@2 @A.A2@ A5.A 2920A A526? ?24B9.A? A5.; 6; A5@2 D52?2 A52 ?24B9.A? 6@ .==6;A21 /F =96A606.;@ )52F .9@ @5D A5.A 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 56452? 6; @A.A2@ A5.A .==6;A A52 ?24B9.A?
  • 12. )56@ @9BA6; 399D@ A52 =?=@.9 /F '4O D5605 0;@6@A@ ; . @20;1 /2@A 0::6A:2;A :205 .;6@: 6; D5605 A52 =?606;4 1206@6; 6@ 12924.A21 A .; 6;12=2;12;A ?24B9.A? D5@2 =?232?2;02@ 1 ;A ;202@@.?69F 06;0612 D6A5 A5@2 3 A52 4C2?;:2;A
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A )52F .@@B:2 A5.A A52 ?24B9.A? 0.;;A /@2?C2 D52A52? 6;C2@A:2;A 5.@ A.82; =9.02 /BA 0.; /@2?C2 A52 H?:J@ AA.9 0@A@ )52F @5D A5.A . =? 6;1B@A?F ?24B9.A? 0.; C2?0:2 A52 ?.A052A 2O20A $B? .?A6092 42;2?.96G2@ A52@2 ?2@B9A@ A . /?.12? 0;A2EA D5605 2;0:=.@@ C.?6B@ :12@ 3 0:=2A6A6; AF=2@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 3?:@ 3 ?24B9.A6; ; .116A6; D2 .99D A52 9246@9.A? A @2A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .#$+ -5(1.-,$-3 ;@612? . ?24B9.A21 1B=9F A5.A 6;09B12@ 3B? =9.F2?@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A52 2;A?.;A A52 ?24B9.A? .;1 A52 9246@9.A? )52 H?: 6@ C2?A60.99F 6;A24?.A21 .;1 D;@ . /AA92;208 6;=BA .;1 0.; 6;C2@A )52 H?: ;9F =2?.A2@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A .;1 5.@ A /BF .002@@ A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208 6;=BA ,2 ?232? A A52 =?602 3 A52 /AA92;208 6;=BA .@ .;1 12;A2 6A /F ,2 6;12E H?:@ D6A5 @B/@0?6=A )52 @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 )52 05@2@ A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; )52 4.:2 5.@ 3B? @A.42@ D5605 B;391 .@ 399D@ ; @A.42 A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; ; @A.42
  • 16. A52 6;0B:/2;A 120612@ D52A52? A 6;C2@A ; @A.42 A52 @20A?.9 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ; @A.42 A52 2;A?.;A 120612@ 63 6A 2;A2?@ A52 :.?82A ? ;A 3A2?D.?1@ A52 H?:@ =9.F @:2 :.?82A 4.:2 ) 822= A52 :129 .@ 42;2?.9 .@ =@@6/92 D2 1 ;A :129 2E=9606A9F A52 :.?82A 4.:2 ;@A2.1 D2 .@@B:2 A5.A A52 :.?82A 4.:2 5.@ . B;6B2 2B696/?6B: F62916;4 ?21B021 3?: =?HA 3B;0A6;@ D6A5 ?2@=20A A D5605 D2 :.82 .@@B:=A6;@ 16?20A9F !.A2? 6; @20A6;@ .;1 D2 D699 =?C612 2E.:=92@ 3 @=206H0 :.?82A 4.:2@ A5.A :22A B? .@@B:=A6;@ 99 ?292C.;A 6;3?:.A6; /20:2@ 0::; 8;D92142 .@ A52 4.:2 B;391@ (1,2 A :645A /2 B@23B9 A A56;8 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208 6;=BA .@ . ;2AD?8 2 4 . A2920::B;60.A6;@ ;2AD?8 .; 2920A?606AF ;2AD?8 ? . ?.69D.F ;2AD?8 A 0@A ; A52 6;0B:/2;A 0.; :.82 .; 6;C2@A:2;A D5605 26A52? B=4?.12@ A52 ;2AD?8 ? 12=9F@ . ;2D .;1 :?2 .1C.;021 ;2AD?8 9@ 3? A52 @.82 3 0;0?2A2;2@@ 6A :645A /2 B@23B9 A A56;8 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A .@ 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 B.96AF 3 ?2A.69 @2?C602@ D2C2? .99
  • 17.
  • 18. 3 B? ?2@B9A@ .9@ .==9F 63 6;@A2.1 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 120?2.@2@ A52 :.?46;.9 0@A 3 ?2A.69 @2?C602@ ,2 D699 B@2 @B=2?@0?6=A A 12;A2 D52A52? A52?2 D.@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ;A ?2@=20A6C29F 2;A2 /F . =.?.:2A2? A5.A :2.@B?2@ A52 B.96AF 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ /AA92;208 6;=BA 46C2; %.?.:2A2? A.82@ C.9B2 63 .;1 C.9B2 ; 63 2;A2 /F A52 4?@@ =?HA 3 H?: 3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F .;1 A52
  • 19. 6;1B@A?F 6@ . :;=9F A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 4?@@ =?HA 6@ 3 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F .;1 A52 6;1B@A?F 6@ . 1B=9F H?: J@ 4?@@ =?HA 6@ $3.1 + $4+ 3.1 )52 ?24B9.A? 6@ B;./92 A 0::6A A . ?24B9.A?F =960F 6 2 A .; .002@@ =?602 2;02 6A :.82@ 6A@ 05602 .3A2? /@2?C6;4 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .@ 6; ?6A 2A .9 2;A2 /F A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6@
  • 20. # 3 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6@ # (06.9 D293.?2 6@ 3 A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F @06.9 D293.?2 6@ '
  • 21. #
  • 22. 3 A52 A52?2 6@ 2;A?F @06.9 D293.?2 6@ ' # )52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ . D2645A21 @B: 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 H?:@J =?HA@ D52?2 .;1 .?2 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA .;1 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ ?2@=20A6C29F D6A5
  • 23. !2A #A2 A5.A )52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 A :.E6:6G2 @B/720A A A52 6;0B: /2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6C2; B? .@@B:=A6;@ ./BA =.FO@ 6;A?1B021 6; @20A6;
  • 24. A52?2 6@ ; ;221 A 46C2 . D2645A 56452? A5.; A A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA )52 9246@9.A? 0.; /A.6; . @6:69.? 2O20A /F .17B@A6;4 A52 D2645A@ A A52 A52? =.?A62@J@ =.FO@
  • 25. $(2+ 3.1 *;9682 A52 ?24B9.A? A52 9246@9.A? 0.; 0::6A A . 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6; =2?5.=@ /20.B@2 A52 9246@9.A6C2 1206@6; =?02@@ A.82@ 9;42? A5.; A52 ?24B9.A?F 1206@6; =?02@@ .;1 9;4 2;B45 3? A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0F092 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? :.82@ 6A@ 05602 /23?2 6;C2@A:2;A ; .116A6; A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ D2645A@ 12=2;16;4 ; D52A52? A52?2 D.@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ;A )56@ .@@B:=A6; 6@ 7B@A6H./92 /20.B@2 A52 ?24B9.A? ;9F 05@2@ A52 .002@@ =?602 .3A2? /@2?C6;4 D52A52? A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@ 6;C2@A21 ? ;A D2C2? 6A ?2B6?2@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 6@ ./92 A D?6A2 0:=92E 9.D@ ; @20A6; D2 0;@612? .9A2?;.A6C2 .@@B:=A6;@ )52 9246@9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ A52 ;2A @06.9 D293.?2 224,/3(.-2 !.43 8.:2 )5?B45BA A52 ?2:.6;12? 3 A52 .?A6092 D2 :.82 A52 399D6;4 .@@B:=A6;@ ./BA =.F O@ )52?2 6@ .; ; @B05 A5.A 63 .;1 ;9F 63
  • 26. ! )52?2 6@ .; ; @B05 A5.A 63 .;1 ;9F 63 # B;0A6;@ .;1 # .?2 0;A6;BB@9F 16O2?2;A6./92 6; 3? .99 ; B;0A6;@ ' .;1 '
  • 28. ? .99
  • 29. 6@ 6;0?2.@6;4 6; .;1 ? .99
  • 30. # 6@ 120?2.@6;4 6; .;1 # #
  • 31. .;1 .?2 A205;60.9 .@@B:=A6;@ 6;A2;121 A .C61 A?6C6.96AF @A.A2@ A5.A 3? . @BN062;A9F 5645 .002@@ =?602 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA /20:2@ ;24.A6C2 .;1 A5.A 3? . @BN062;A9F 9D .002@@ =?602 =@@6/9F ;24.A6C2 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA /20:2@ ;24.A6C2 ; .116A6; A52?2 .?2 .002@@ =?602@ @B05 A5.A /A5 H?:@ 5.C2 =@6A6C2 =?HA@ @A.A2@ A5.A A52 6;C2@A:2;A 6:=?C2@ D293.?2 .99 29@2 0;@A.;A
  • 32. .;1 .?2 A52 @B/@A.;A6C2 .@@B:=A6;@ 3 B? .==?.05
  • 33. @A.A2@ A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6@ 6;0?2.@6;4 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 .;1 0.; /2 7B@A6H21 .@ 399D@ ; 00?16;4 A (=B9/2? .;1 2@.;8 AF=60.99F .1:6;6@A?.A6C2 ?24B9.A?@ .?2 2@A./96@521 /23?2 A52 20;:60 =.?.:2A2?@ A5.A .O20A ?24B9.A?F BA0:2@ .?2 /@2?C21 2;02 @A.ABA?F 0;@A?.6;A@ =?C612 . :2.;@ 3 0::6A:2;A 3? A52 9246@9.AB?2 A5.A ?2@A?60A@ 3BAB?2 ?24B9.A?F 1206@6;@
  • 34. 6;0?2.@2 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 6;0?2.@2@ A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 0@A .1C.;A.42 C2? 6A@ ?6C.9 .;1 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ D592@.92 :.?46; D2C2? 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 .002@@ =?602 5.@ A52 ;24.A6C2 2O20A 3 120?2.@6;4 A52 ;B:/2? 3 B;6A@ @91 /F A52 2;A?.;A ,2 .@@B:2 A52 9.AA2? 2O20A 6@ .9D.F@ D2.82? A5.; A52 @B: 3 A52 AD 3?:2? 2O20A@ @ A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6;0?2.@2@ D6A5 A52 .002@@ =?602 @A.A2@ A5.A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6@ 120?2.@6;4 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 .;1 0.; /2 7B@A6H21 .@ 399D@ )52 56452? A52 .002@@ =?602 A52 56452? A52 2;A?.;AJ@ :.?46;.9 0@A 6@ .;1 A5B@ A52 56452? A52 ?2A.69 =?602 6A 05.?42@ ; .116A6; A52 6;0B:/2;A 6@ 92@@ D??621 ./BA 9@6;4 @B/@0?6/2?@ A A52 2;A?.;A /20.B@2 A52 6;0?2.@2 6; A52 D592@.92 ?2C2;B2@ 0:=2;@.A2 3? A56@ @ . ?2@B9A A52 =?602@ 3 /A5 H?:@ 6;0?2.@2 A52?2/F 120?2.@6;4 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@
  • 35. 04(+(!1(4, .-$/3 )52 @B/ 4.:2 =2?320A #.@5 2B696/?6B: 6@ ( . @2A 3 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; (( .; 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; ((( .; .002@@ =?602 A A52 ;2AD?8 .;1 (5 . 1206@6; 3 D52A52? A 2;A2? A52 :.?82A @B05 A5.A A52 1206@6; A 2;A2? A52 :.?82A :.E6:6G2@ A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA@ 46C2; A52 @2A 3 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .;1 A52 .002@@ =?602@ A52 .002@@ =?602 3? ;2AD?8 :.E6:6G2@ A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 46C2; A52 @2A 3 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; .;1 A52 =A6:.9 2;A?F 1206@6; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; :.E6:6G2@ A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA@ 46C2; A52 @2A 3 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602@ .;1 A52 =A6:.9 2;A?F 1206@6; A52 @2A 3 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; :.E6:6G2@ @06.9 D293.?2 46C2; A52 =A6:.9 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; A52 =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602@ .;1 A52 =A6:.9 2;A?F 1206@6; 04(+(!1(4, .% ,$ ; A56@ (20A6; D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 2B696/?6B: 3 A52 4.:2 D5605 D2 0;@A?B0A /F D?86;4 /.08D.?1@ 3 $ -318 $(2(.- #2EA D2 12A2?:6;2 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =A6:.9 1206@6; 3 D52A52? A 2;A2? A52 :.?82A ,52; 6;16O2?2;A /2AD22; 2;A2?6;4 .;1 ;A 2;A2?6;4 A52 2;A?.;A 05@2@ A52 3?:2?
  • 36. 6C2; . A52 2;A?.;A 05@2@ ;A A 2;A2? .;1 A52 :.?82A 6@ . :;=9F 63 .;1 ;9F 63 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@
  • 37. 2;02 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 4?@@ =?HA 6@ 46C2; /F 63
  • 38. 63
  • 39. A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA /F 63 63
  • 41. 63
  • 42. .;1 @06.9 D293.?2 /F ' 63 '
  • 43. 63
  • 44. 3 $ $4+ 3(.- .% 3'$ $22 1($ #2EA D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602 05602 6?@A D2 12H;2 A52 @06.99F =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602 ? A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ C69.A21 ?
  • 45. A52?2 6@ ; 2;A?F .;1 /20:2@ 6??292C.;A 2;02 A52 :.?82A 6@ . 1B=9F 63 6@ ;
  • 46. 2;A2 /F A52 .002@@ =?602 A5.A :.E6:6G2@ D293.?2 46C2; A5.A A52?2 6@ 2;A?F .;1 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@ :.12 6A@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; 6 2 ( ' ; @@B:2 A5.A 6@ B;6B2 A @6:=96H2@ 2E=@6A6; A 12;A2 /F
  • 47. .; .?/6A?.?F 292:2;A 3 2;A2 /F A52 # .002@@ =?602 6 2 (
  • 48. ; +.9B2 2E6@A@ /20.B@2
  • 50.
  • 51. $/C6B@9F 63 ' '
  • 52. .;1
  • 53. A52?D6@2 ; A52 9.A2? 0.@2 6A 6@ @06.99F =A6:.9 A 6:=@2 ; .002@@ /964.A6;@ F 12H;6A6; 6;C9C2@ . D293.?2 9@@ ,2 1 ;A :129 2E=9606A9F A52 :.?82A 4.:2 B;A69 @20A6; D2C2? A 6;A2?=?2A @:2 3 B? ?2@B9A@ 6; @20A6; 6A 6@ B@23B9 A 822= 6; :6;1 A5.A A52@2 D293.?2 9@@2@ .?2 0.B@21 /F A52 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A 4
  • 54. 6;0?2.@2@ ?2A.69 =?602@ .;1 A52?2/F A52 12.1D2645A 9@@ ./C2 A52 @06.99F =A6:B: 6C2; A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =A6:.9 2;A?F 1206@6; A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ 63 #
  • 55. # 63
  • 56. )52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ 2B6C.92;A A 6@ ; 2;A2 /F A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =A6:.9 1206@6; ? ; A52 399D6;4 H?@A ?12? 0;16A6; 591@ # )52 ;2EA !2::. 12@0?6/2@ 5D A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602 C.?62@ D6A5 A52 D2645A@ 3? 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA $,, 1..% !2A A 399D@ 3?: A52 12H;6A6; 3 6;A2?6? :.E6:B: .;1 A52 6:=9606A 3B;0A6; A52?2: A5.A
  • 57.
  • 58. # # #
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61. # # # # )52;
  • 62. .;1 6:=9F A5.A !2A
  • 63. ? *;12? A52@2 0;16A6;@ 0.; ;9F 120?2.@2 6;0?2.@2 .;1 ;9F 63 6;0?2.@2@ ,52; :.F 120?2.@2 ? 6;0?2.@2 63 ? 6;0?2.@2@ ?2@=20A6C29F 3 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99 =.?A62@ 6; A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A52 ?24B9.A? :.E6:6G2@ @06.9 D293.?2 .;1 @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 .A A52 ,2 .@@B:2 A5.A A52 9246@9.A? =?C612@ A52 ?24B9.A? D6A5 . A62 /?2.86;4 ?B92 2 4 05@2 A52 9D2@A C.9B2 ? A52 56452@A C.9B2 @B05 A5.A A52 =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602 6@ B;6B2
  • 64. # 92C29 3 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ @BN062;A9F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ A5.; A H?:@J =?HA@
  • 65. A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 /29D A52 # 92C29 =?C6121 A5.A
  • 66. ? . @BN062;A9F 5645 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A /20:2@ /6;16;4 6;.99F 63 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ @BN062;A9F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA A5.; A A52 A52? =.?A62@J =.FO@
  • 67. A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 # 92C29
  • 69. 4.6; 3? . @BN062;A9F 5645 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ C69.A21 .;1 A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@
  • 70. ? 2B6C.92;A9F 12@ ;A 6:=@2 .;F =2; .002@@ /964.A6;@ 2;A2 /F A52 9D2@A C.9B2 3 A52 D2645A 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B: /2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ /6;16;4 6 2 .;1 12;A2 /F A52 9D2@A D2645A 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA @B05 A5.A A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@
  • 71. 3 $ -5$23,$-3 $(2(.- #2EA D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =A6:.9 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; 2;A2 A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 6;C2@A:2;A 4?@@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A@ /F )52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 63 A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ; @:.992? A5.; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A ;C2@A:2;A 5.@ AD 2O20A@ 6?@A 6A 5.@ . 16?20A 2O20A C2? A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA (20;1 6A 5.@ .; 6;16?20A 2O20A 3 6;1B06;4 . 05.;42 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 )52 ;2EA !2::. 12@0?6/2@ 5D A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 6;C2@A:2;A C.?62@ D6A5 A52 D2645A@ 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6; A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; $,, 1..% 99D@ 3?:
  • 72. .;1 !2::. ?: 2B.A6; A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 6;0?2.@6;4 6; .;1 120?2.@6;4 6; ?: !2::. 6@ ;; 120?2.@6;4 6; .;1 ;; 6;0?2.@6;4 6; A 6@ .9@ =@@6/92 A5.A 6; D5605 0.@2 . 56452? D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ DB91 :.82 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ =A6:.9 .002@@ =?602 2B.9 A A52 H?@A /2@A
  • 73. 2;02 /F @2AA6;4 5645 C.9B2@ 3? .;1 ? /F @2AA6;4 5645 C.9B2@ 3? .;1 A52 9246@9.A? 0.; ?2@=20A6C29F 2;0B?.42 ? 16@0B?.42 6;C2@A:2;A 6C2; !2::.
  • 75. 2;02 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A ;9F 63 6@ ; 3 $ $('32 .% $4+ 3.192 !)$3(5$ 4-3(.- #2EA D2 05.?.0A2?6G2 A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 D2645A 05602 1206@6; ,2 @A.?A /F 12H;6;4 @:2 6:=?A.;A A5?2@591@ 2;A2 /F A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 @06.9 D293.?2 3 6; C2@A:2;A )52 9246@9.A? D52; @2AA6;4 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 05@2@ 6;16?20A9F A52 .002@@ =?602@ ; 16;4 @ 6A 3.02@ . A?.12 O $; A52 ;2 5.;1 3?:
  • 76. A52 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A .?2 56452? A52 56452? 6@ 0:=.?21 A $; A52 A52? 5.;1 3? A52?2 6@ . D293.?2 9@@ 0.B@21 /F A52 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ D293.?2 46C2; A5.A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ ;A 16@A?A21 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 6 2 46C2; 6:=962@ 6@ ; ,2 D699 @.F A5.A 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ # 63 6A 6;0?2.@2@ @06.9 D293.?2 2C.9B.A21 .A A52 # .002@@ =?602@ 6 2
  • 77. .;1 A5.A 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ 63 46C2; A52 .002@@ =?602@ @2A /F A52 ?24B9.A? 6A 6;0?2.@2@ @06.9 D293.?2 62
  • 78. #.AB?.99F 3? ; A52 9246@9.A? 12@ ;A D.;A A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 46C2; A5.A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ ;A 16@A?A21 6 2
  • 79. +.9B2 :.F /2 2B.9 A G2? 63 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 4?@@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 12@ ;A 6;0?2.@2 D6A5 6;C2@A:2;A 3? ,2 D699 @.F A5.A A52?2 6@ 63 A52 6;0B:/2;A 12@ ;A 6;C2@A D52; 6;C2@A :2;A 6@ # .;1 A5.A A52?2 6@ 63 A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ D52; 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A . # )56@ 6@ A52 0.@2 3 A52 A2996;4 :129 =?2@2;A21 6; @20A6; .;1 A52 @F::2A?60 B?;A :129 =?2@2;A21 6; @20A6;
  • 80. ; A52 ./@2;02 3 16@A?A6;@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 63 A52?2 :.F /2 .;1 63 A52?2 :.F /2 )52 399D6;4 .@@B:=A6; @A.A2@ B;12? D5605 0;16A6;@ A52?2 :.F /2 . .;1 / ?2@=20A6C29F !2A ! !2A
  • 81. ; A52 ?2:.6;12? 3 A52 .?A6092 2E02=A 6; @20A6; D2 .@@B:2 A5.A . 591@ ? ; A52 9246@9.A? 0.; @2A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; A /2 2B.9 A @06.9 D293.?2 ? ; A52 9246@9.A? 0.; ;9F 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A /F 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F 3?: @06.9 D293.?2 .A 92.@A 6; A52 ; 6;C2@A:2;A 0.@2 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 46C2; .;1
  • 83. 6@ ; ? ; 6;C2@A:2;A 00B?@ D6A5BA .;F 16@A?A6; 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A 6 2 00B?@ D6A5 .;1 ? .9A2?;.A6C29F D6A5 .;1 99 A5.A 6@ ?2B6?21 6@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ D2645A@ 3? A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ /6;16;4 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 3 A52 9246@9.A? 6@ ./92 A 6;1B02 # 6;C2@A:2;A D6A5BA 16@A?A6;@ 7B@A /F A5?2.A2;6;4 A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 56452? D2645A ; 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A )52 399D6;4 .@@B:=A6; @A.A2@ B;12? D5605 0;16A6;@ A56@ :.F ? :.F ;A 00B? ?2@=20A6C29F
  • 84. !2A ! !2A
  • 85. )52 ;2EA !2::. @B::.?6G2@ A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 1206@6; D52; 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 # 6;C2@A:2;A D6A5BA 16@A?A6;@ $,,
  • 86.
  • 87. ! ! #2EA D2 0;@612? A52 0.@2 D52?2 / 591@ ,2 @A.?A /F 12A2?:6;6;4 A52 /2@A D.F 3?: A52 9246@9.A?J@ =2?@=20A6C2 3 6;1B06;4 6;C2@A:2;A ? ; 6;C2@A:2;A 00B?@ D6A5BA .;F 16@A?A6; 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A .@ 2E=9.6;21 ./C2
  • 88. ? ; A52 9246@9.A? 0.; ;9F 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A /2 16@A?A6;4 A52 ?2 A.69 :.?82A 6 2 D6A5
  • 89. 2;02 A 12A2?:6;2 A52 /2@A D.F 3 6;1B06;4 6;C2@A:2;A A52 9246@9.A? 05@2@ .;1 A :.E6:6G2 D293.?2 @B/720A A A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;16C61B.9 =.?A606=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 2;02 6A @5B91 @2A A ?29.E A52 0;@A?.6;A 2;A2 /F A52 9D2@A D2645A 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA A5.A :.E6:6G2@ D293.?2 46C2; A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ ( +.9B2 6@ 56452? A5.; .;1 ;; 120?2.@6;4 6; ,2 ;D 2@A./96@5 B;12? D5605 0;16A6;@ 6;1B06;4 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ D293.?2 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 @06.99F 12@6?./92 6;C2@A:2;A 46C2; A5.A ( 92.?9F 6@ ;
  • 90. ; =.?A60B9.? D2 :.F 5.C2
  • 91.
  • 92. 3? D5605 6:=962@ A5.A .9A5B45 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ @06.99F 12@6?./92 3? 56452? C.9B2@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6A 6@ 6:=@@6/92 A 6;1B02 A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A ; A56@ 0.@2
  • 93. ? ; 6A 6@ =@@6/92 A 6;1B02 A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A B?A52?:?2 6;C2@A :2;A 6@ @06.99F 12@6?./92 6 2 A52 D293.?2 /2;2HA@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A BAD2645 A52 D293.?2 9@@ 0.B@21 /F A52 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A 6;1B021 /F
  • 94. 2;02 A52 3 A52 D293.?2 3B;0A6; 6@ 120?2.@6;4 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 3? .;F A52 0;@A?.6;A 6@ /6;16;4 .A 6 2 A52 9246@9.A? @5B91 05@2 A52 9D2@A D2645A ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 3 ; A52 A52? 5.;1 A52 D293.?2 3B;0A6; 6@ ;; :;A;60 3? D2 :.F 5.C2 .A ; A56@ 0.@2 6@ 6;12=2;12;A 3 )52 D293.?2 3B;0A6; 6@ 120?2.@6;4 6; A52 0.@2 3 B?;A 0:=2A6A6; .;1 ;; :;A;60 6; A52 0.@2 3 A2996;4 :129 /A5 =?2@2;A21 6; @20A6; B;0A6; 6@ ;; 6;0?2.@6;4 6; A52 56452? 6@ A52 @A?;42? A52 0;@A?.6;A A5.A 92.1@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A
  • 95.
  • 96. 9246@9.A? @A699 =?232?@ A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 @2A@
  • 97. )52 D2645A 46C2; A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA :.F /2 @B05 A5.A A52 ?24B9.A? 6;1B02@ . :;=9F )56@ 5.==2;@ 63 /BA ;A ;9F 63 6@ ; ; A56@ 0.@2 A52 6;0B:/2;A DB91 ;2C2? 6;C2@A 63 A52?2 6@ . 1B=9F .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 A52 9246@9.A? DB91 =?232? . :;=9F .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A A . 1B=9F D6A5BA 6;C2@A:2;A ? ; 6A 6@ 26A52? 6:=@@6/92 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A ? 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ @06.99F B;12@6?./92 6 2 A52 C.9B2 3 ?2B6?21 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ @ 5645 A5.A A52 D293.?2 9@@ 0.B@21 /F A52 .@@06.A21 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 ?2A.69 :.?82A BAD2645 A52 D293.?2 /2;2HA@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? 12@ ;A D.;A A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 46C2@ 2B.9 D2645A@ A .99 =.?A62@J =.FO@ !2::.
  • 98. @B:@ B= A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 1206@6; 3? A52 0.@2 D52?2 6;1B06;4 # 6;C2@A:2;A :.F 6;C9C2 16@A?A6;@ $,,
  • 99.
  • 100. ! .;1 ! .;1 ! .;1 )52 9246@9.A?J@ ./696AF A 16@A?A A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; .D.F 3?: @06.9 D293.?2 6 2 A52 ./696AF 3 @2AA6;4
  • 101. .99D@ 6;1B06;4 # 6;C2@A:2;A 3? ; /BA ;A 3? ; ;1B06;4 6;C2@A:2;A 3? ; ?2B6?2@ 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A ;1B06;4 6;C2@A:2;A 3? ; ?2B6?2@ /A5 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 D2645A 3 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 6;0?2.@6;4 A52 D2645A 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A 04(+(!1(4, .% 3'$ '.+$ ,$ )52 ;2EA %?=@6A6; @B::.?6G2@ A52 2B696/?6B: 3 A52 D592 4.:2 1./.2(3(.-
  • 102.
  • 103. ; A52 0.@2 3 ;
  • 104. A52 9246@9.A? 0B91 @2A D2645A@ @B05 A5.A A52 ?24B9.A? DB91 :.E6:6G2 @06.9 D293.?2 6; 0.@2 3 ; 6;C2@A:2;A D2C2? 3? 2E=@6A6; 0;C2;62;02 .;1 46C2; A52 D293.?2 2B6C.92;02 D2 .@@B:2 A5.A A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52 D2645A@ .@ 3? A52 0.@2 3
  • 105.
  • 106. ! ! !
  • 107.
  • 108. ! ! ! 1..% 99D@ 3?: !2::.
  • 109. .;1
  • 110. 3 . 591@ A52 9246@9.A? 6@ .9D.F@ ./92 A 6;1B02 # 6;C2@A:2;A /F A5?2.A 2;6;4 A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 3 / 591@ D52; 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ . # A52?2 .?2 A5?22 AF=2@ 3 2B696/?6. 12=2;16;4 ; A52 C.9B2 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6?@A 63 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D 6 2 63 6@ ; A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99 =.?A62@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 112. 6;C9C2@ . 0?216/92 BA 3 A52 2B696/?6B: A5?2.A A A52 6;0B:/2;A 3 3.06;4 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A )56@ 6;1B02@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A (20;1 63 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A A.82@ 6;A2?:216.A2 C.9B2@ 6 2 63 6@ ; A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 113. .;1 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 114. ; A52? D?1@ ;D A52 9246@9.A? ;A ;9F A5?2.A2;@ A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A /BA .9@ ?2D.?1@ A52 6;0B:/2;A D6A5 . 5645 .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 115. 4.6; A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ )56?1 63 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 6 2 63 6@ ; 6A 6@ 6:=@@6/92 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A ? A52 16@A?A6;@ A52 9246@9.A? ;221@ A 6:=@2 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 A 5645 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645A A A52 =.FO 3 .99 =.?A62@ D52A52? A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ;A .;1 A52 6;0B:/2;A 12@ ;A 6;C2@A #A2 A5.A 6; .;F 0.@2 D52; 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A . # 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ A52 @.:2 D2645 A A52 =.FO@ 3 .99 =.?A62@ D52A52? A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A ? ;A A 16@0B?.42 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 116. (B::6;4 B= A52 9246@9.A? /F @2AA6;4 A52 D2645A@ A A52 ?24B9.A? /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6;1B02@ A52 ?24B9.A? A 05@2 .; .002@@ =?602 .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 2B.9 A A52 ;2 3 .; 5F=A52A60.9 ?24B9.A? ./92 A 0::6A A .; .002@@ =?602 /23?2 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 117. .-24,$1 41/+42 #2EA D2 12A2?:6;2 63 0;@B:2?@ .?2 /2AA2? O D6A5 A52 =@@6/696AF 3 A52 ?24B9.A? 46C6;4 ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA@ A5.; A A52 =.FO@ 3 A52 A52? =.?A62@ 00?16;4 A %?=@6A6; A52 9246@9.A? D699 ;9F 46C2 ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 / 591@ .;1 6; =.?A60B9.? ;9F 3? ; ; A56@ 0.@2 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A A 6;1B02 A52 ?24B9.A? A @2A A52 .002@@ =?602 ./C2 A52 # 92C29 :=.?21 A . 0;A2EA D52?2 A52 D2645A@ 46C2; A A52 =9.F2?@J =.FO@ .?2 .99 2B.9 6A 6@ =A6:.9 3? 0;@B:2?@ A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 63 ;202@@.?F 0;16A6; 3? A52 ./C2 A 591 3? ; 6@ A5.A 0;@B:2?@ /2;2HA 3?: 6;C2@A:2;A D52; A52 ?24B9.A? :.E6:6G2@ A52 @06.9 D293.?2 3B;0A6; .;1 @2A@ 62 63
  • 118. )56@ :A6C.A2@ A52 ;2EA .@@B:=A6; !2A
  • 119. 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 0;@B:2?@ .?2 6;16O2?2;A /2AD22; /BF6;4 @2?C602@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A D52; A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA
  • 120. .;1 /BF6;4 @2?C602@ 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A D52; A52 .002@@ =?602 2B.9@ )52 ;2EA !2::. =?2@2;A@ A52 ?.;42 3 =.?.:2A2?@ 3? D5605 0;@B:2?@ .?2 /2AA2? O D6A5 A52 =960F 3 46C6;4 ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA@ A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A $,,
  • 121.
  • 122.
  • 123. !
  • 124. ! 1..% 6C2; .@@B:=A6; .;1 8;D6;4 /F !2::. A5.A 6@ ;; 6;0?2.@6;4 6; D5605 6@ ;; 120?2.@6;4 6; D2 5.C2 @@B:6;4 A5.A
  • 125. A52; 6:=962@ 3? .99 3 A52?2 6@ . @B05 A5.A 63 .;1 ;9F 63
  • 126. 3 0;@B:2?@ D699 ;2C2? /2 D?@2 O 63 A52 ?24B9.A? 46C2@ ?29.A6C29F :?2 D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA $A52?D6@2 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ :.F 120?2.@2 ? 6;0?2.@2 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 9D A52 16@A?A6;@ 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 ?2@B9A6;4 3?: A52 9246@9.A? @2AA6;4 . 56452? D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 .9@ 9D 2;02 0;@B:2?@ .?2 /2AA2? O D6A5 A56@ =960F 12@=6A2 5.C6;4 A =.F 56452? ?2A.69 =?602@ /20.B@2 A52F 0;@B:2 56452? B.96AF @2?C602@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 16@A?A6;@ ?2B6?21 A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A .?2 56452? .;1 A52?23?2 ?2A.69 =?602@ .?2 .9@ 56452? .;1 0;@B:2?@ :.F /2 D?@2 O 12@=6A2 A52 3.0A A5.A A52F ;D 5.C2 56452? B.96AF @2?C602@ .C.69./92 7 ,/+$2 ; A56@ (20A6; D2 =?2@2;A AD :129@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A6; 96A2?.AB?2 A5.A 3B9H99 B? .@@B:= A6;@ ; =.FO@ .3$++(- 6(3' $ 3(5$+8 +./$# $, -#2 )52 H?@A 2E.:=92 D2 =?2@2;A 6@ @6:69.? A A52 ;2 3 649.6@2? .;1 2?./. .;1 ?6A 2A .9 )56@ :129 .@@B:2@ 0;@B:2?@ .?2 B;63?:9F 16@A?6/BA21 .9;4 . A2996;4 96;2 3.06;4 A?.;@=?A.A6; 0@A@ $( A A?.C29 16@A.;02 ( .05 0;@B:2? 5.@ . 12:.;1 3B;0A6; 46C2; /F ! ) D52?2 ! 6@ A52 ;B:/2? 3 B;6A@ =B?05.@21 3?: H?: 6@ A52 =2? B;6A =?602 3 A52 @2?C602@ 3 H?: .;1 ) 6@ . 12:.;1 =.?.:2A2? .@@B:21 A /2 @BN062;A9F 9.?42 ?2C2? .@@B:2 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ D592@.92 :.?46;.9 0@A 6@ 0;@A.;A .;1 2B.9 A D5692 6A@ ?2A.69 .0A6C6A62@ 5.C2 . G2? :.?46;.9 0@A )52 2;A?.;A 5.@ :.?46;.9 0@A@ ;
  • 127. 63 6A B@2@ ;2AD?8 6?:@ 05.?42 0;@B:2?@ AD =.?A $ )56@ 3B99 0;@B:2? =.?A606=.A6; :129 C2?6H2@ B? .@@B:=A6;@ A . .;1 .;1 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ =?HA@ .?2 6;C.?6.;A A 6;C2@A:2;A )52 # .002@@ =?602 6@ 2B.9 A :.?46;.9 0@A 3? D5605 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA@ 4?@@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A .?2 =@6A6C2 /BA 6;C.?6.;A A 6;C2@A:2;A 2;02 63 A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2
  • 128. 3B;0A6; A /2 2B.9 A @06.9 D293.?2 A52 6;0B:/2;A D699 ;A 6;C2@A 3? .;F 6 2 ,52; A52 9246@9.A? 6@ ./92 A @2A D2645A@ 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; 6A :B@A 6;A?1B02 16@A?A6;@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A D52;
  • 129. $ ;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A . # 3?
  • 130. ) 2;02 . 591@ 63 .;1 ;9F 63 $
  • 131.
  • 132. ) )52 @.:2 /.@2 :129 0.; /2 B@21 3? .; 2E.:=92 3 6;C2@A:2;A 6; 0@A ?21B0A6; ; A56@ 0.@2 D2 DB91 5.C2 . ?21B0A6; 6; A52 :.?46;.9 0@A 3 6; A52 0.@2 3 6;C2@A:2;A 4.6; A52 # .002@@ =?602 6@ 2B.9 A :.?46;.9 0@A 6 2 6; 0.@2 3 ; 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 6; 0.@2 3 6;C2@A:2;A 2;02 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA@ .?2 6;C.?6.;A A 6;C2@A:2;A .A A52 # .002@@ =?602 6 2 .;1 A52 9246@9.A? ;221@ A =B;6@5 A52 6;0B:/2;A 3? ;A 6;C2@A6;4 ?
  • 133. $ 6A :B@A .116A6;.99F ?2D.?1 A52 6;0B:/2;A 3? 6;C2@A6;4 4.6; . 591@ 63 .;1 ;9F 63 $
  • 134.
  • 135. ) 4 -3(38 .,/$3(3(.- 6(3' .,/+$3$ /(++.5$12 ;@612? ;D . :129 @6:69.? A A52 ;2 =?2@2;A21 6; ?@ .;1 A.8?=6 @@B:2 0;@B:2?@ 5.C2 B;6A 12:.;1@ .;1 .?2 52A2?42;2B@ 6; A526? /.@60 D6996;4;2@@ A =.F )56@ :129 6@ 3 =.?A6.9 0;@B:2? =.?A606=.A6; .;1 46C2@ ?646; A 12:.;1 3B;0A6;@ ) ! ! D52?2 ! 6@ A52 ;B:/2? 3 B;6A@ =B?05.@21 3?: H?: 6@ A52 =2? B;6A =?602 3 A52 @2?C602@ 3 H?: ) 6@ A52 ?2@2?C.A6; =?602 3 H?: )52 :129 6; ?@ .@@B:2@ 6;0:=92A2 @=699C2?@ /BA 3? ;D D2 D699 .@@B:2 A5.A @=699C2?@ .?2 0:=92A2 @ A5.A /A5 12:.;1 3B;0A6;@ 6;0?2.@2 /F D6A5 6;C2@A:2;A '24.?16;4 A52 @B==9F @612 D2 :.82 A52 @.:2 .@@B:=A6;@ .@ 6; A52 2E.:=92 3 @20A6; 6?:@ 05.?42 0;@B:2?@ 96;2.? $ )56@ :129 C2?6H2@ B? .@@B:=A6;@ A . .;1 3 H?:@ .?2 @F: :2A?60 6 2 ) ) ) A52; A52 # .002@@ =?602 6@ @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =.?A60 6=.A6; 0;@A?.6;A 6@ /6;16;4 6 2 .;1 6A 6@ 6:=@@6/92 3? A52 ?24B9.A? A =B;6@5 A52 6;0B:/2;A 6; A52 0.@2 3 ; 6;C2@A:2;A )56@ 6:=962@ A5.A )5B@ / 591@ 3? .99 =.?.:2A2? C.9B2@ .;1 A52 9246@9.A? 5.@ ;202@@.?69F A 46C2 . 56452? D2645A A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6; 0.@2 3 6;C2@A:2;A D52;2C2? 6A D.;A@ A 6;1B02 6;C2@A:2;A 3 ; A52 A52? 5.;1 A52 6;0B:/2;A 5.@ . @BN062;A9F 5645 6;6A6.9 B.96AF .1C.;A.42 C2? A52 2;A?.;A 6 2 )
  • 136. ) A52 # .002@@ =?602 6@ @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A /A.6;@ =@6A6C2 =?HA@ A5B@ /A5 .;1 .?2 =@6A6C2 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ .1C.;A.42 6@ @BN062;A9F 5645 6 2 )
  • 137. )
  • 138. 2C2; D52; :.E6:6G6;4 @06.9 D293.?2 A52 ?24B9.A? =?232?@ A 6;1B02 . :;=9F 6 2
  • 139. A5B@ 4.6; @6:69.? ?2@B9A@ 591 3? .; 6;C2@A:2;A 6; 0@A ?21B0A6;
  • 140. 73$-2(.-2 ; A56@ @20A6; D2 =?2@2;A A5?22 2EA2;@6;@ A A52 :129 ; A52 H?@A 2EA2;@6; A52?2 :.F /2 C2? 6;C2@A:2;A ; A52 @20;1 2EA2;@6; A52 9246@9.A? 6@ B;./92 A @2A D2645A@ 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; 3 A52 6;0B:/2;A ; A52 A56?1 2EA2;@6; A52 ?24B9.A? @2A@ ?2A.69 =?602@ 6;@A2.1 3 .002@@ =?602@ 5$1 (-5$23,$-3 #2EA D2 D699 .;.9FG2 A52 0.@2 3 ;@612? A52 :129 3 @20A6;
  • 141. .;1 .@@B:2 A5.A / 591@ 6 2 A5.A
  • 142. ; A56@ 0.@2 . ;202@@.?69F 591@ @6;02 @ D2 .?4B21 /23?2 B;12? A52@2 06?0B:@A.;02@ .;1 D52;2C2? 6@ ; 3? A52 # .002@@ =?602@ A52?2 6@ 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? @5B91 16@@B.12 A52 6;0B:/2;A 3?: 6;C2@A6;4 99D6;4 A52 @.:2 ?2.@;6;4 .@ /23?2 A52 9246@9.A? 16@0B?.42@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A 6;C2@A D6A5 A52 A5?2.A 3 . 9D .002@@ =?602 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A )52 ;2EA !2::. @B::.?6G2@ A52 9246@9.A?J@ =A6:.9 =960F $,,
  • 143. ! ! 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ 5645 A52 9246@9.A? 46C2@ :?2 D2645A A A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A
  • 144. A5?2.A2;6;4 D6A5 . 9D .002@@ =?602 )56@ 16@@B.12@ A52 6;0B:/2;A 3?: 6;C2@A6;4 7 ,/+$ 4 -3(38 .,/$3(3(.- 6(3' -.,/+$3$ /(++.5$12 $C2? 6;C2@A:2;A 42;2?.99F 00B?@ 63 A52 /B@6;2@@ @A2.96;4 2O20A 3 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ C2?F @A?;4 )56@ 6@ A52 0.@2 63 6;C2@A:2;A 5.@ 6;0:=92A2 @=699C2?@ 6 2 63 6;C2@A:2;A /2;2HA@ :?2 A52 B.96AF 3 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ @2?C602@ A5.; A52 B.96AF 3 A52 2;A?.;AJ@ @2?C602@ ;@612? A52 @.:2 :129 .@ 6; @20A6; /BA ;D .@@B:2 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ 6A@ 12:.;1 /F /BA ;9F 6;0?2.@2@ A52 2;A?.;AJ@ 12:.;1 /F D6A5
  • 145.
  • 146. .;1
  • 147.
  • 148. ; A56@ 0.@2 6;C2@A:2;A .99D@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A /20:2 . :;=96@A ; 3.0A 6;C2@A:2;A ;A ;9F .99D@ A52 6;0B:/2;A A D6; . B.96AF .1C.;A.42 C2? A52 2;A?.;A /BA 6A .9@ 92.1@ A52 # .002@@ =?602 A /2 @B05 A5.A A52 2;A?.;A 12@ ;A 2;A2? A52 :.?82A )56@ 5.==2;@ /20.B@2 @6;02 A52 6;0B:/2;A ;D 5.@ . B.96AF .1C.;A.42 6A 6@ @06.99F =?232?./92 A 5.C2 :?2 0;@B:2?@ /BF6;4 @2?C602@ 3?: A52 6;0B:/2;A A5.; 3?: A52 2;A?.;A (6;02 D6A5BA 6;C2@A:2;A A52 # .002@@ =?602 6@ @B05 A5.A A52 6;0B:/2;A 2.?;@ G2? =?HA@ D5692 .3A2? 6;C2@A:2;A 6A 6@ @B05 A5.A 6A /20:2@ . :;=96@A A52 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A /F A52 6;0B:/2;A .?2 C2?F 5645 $; A52 0;A?.?F A52 @06.9 4.6;@ 3 6;C2@A:2;A .9A5B45 =@6A6C2 .?2 ;A C2?F 5645 @6;02 6;C2@A:2;A 6;1B02@ A52 2;A?.;A A @A.F BA 3 A52 :.?82A )52?23?2 3? ;
  • 149. A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 3? A52 # .002@@ =?602@ /BA 6;C2@A:2;A 6@ ;A . # 2;02 A52 9246@9.A? @5B91 16@@B.12 A52 6;0B:/2;A 3?: 6;C2@A6;4 /F 46C6;4 :?2 D2645A A A52 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ -5$23,$-3 -#$/$-#$-3 $('32 #2EA D2 0;@612? A52 0.@2 D52?2 A52 9246@9.A? 6@ 0;@A?.6;21 A D?6A2 @6:=92 9.D@ ?2 @=206H0.99F A52 9246@9.A? 6@ B;./92 A @2A A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; ;@612? A52 :129 3 @20A6;
  • 150. 2E02=A A5.A A52 9246@9.A? 6@ B;./92 A @2A A52 D2645A@ 3 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; )52 2B696/?6B: 3 A52 AD 9.@A @A.42@ 3 A52 4.:2 ?2:.6;@ B;05.;421 2;02 D2 D699 ;9F .;.9FG2 A52 H?@A AD @A.42@ 3 A52 4.:2 -5$23,$-3 $(2(.- ; A56@ 0.@2 A52 9246@9.A?J@ 05602 C.?6./92@ .C.69./92 .?2 )52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 4?@@ 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 6@ A52; 46C2; /F ;C2@A:2;A 00B?@ 63 ;A?.?F A A52 @02;.?6 D52?2 A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ D2645A@ 0;16A6;.9 ; A52 6;C2@A:2;A 1206@6; A52 ?29.A6;@56= /2AD22; A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 6;C2@A:2;A .;1 A52 D2645A@ 3 A52 ?24B9.A?J@ /720A6C2 3B;0A6; 6@ ;A @A?.645A3?D.?1 ; 3.0A A52 56452? A52 D2645A 3?
  • 151. 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA @2A /F A52 9246@9.A? A52 9D2? 56452? A52 .002@@ =?602 A52 ?24B9.A? D699 @2A /A5 A ;2AD?8 .;1 )52 ;2EA !2::. 12@0?6/2@ 5D A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 =?HA 3 6;C2@A:2;A C.?62@ D6A5 A52 D2645A@ 3? 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ .;1 A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA $,,
  • 152. 1..% 99D@ 6::216.A29F 3?: A52 12?6C.A6C2 3 .@@B:=A6;
  • 153. .;1 !2::. (6;02 6;C2@A:2;A 6:=962@ . 56452? ;B:/2? 3 B;6A@ @91 /F A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ D592@.92 B;6A D2 2E=20A A52 6:=.0A 3 .; 6;0?2.@2 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 ; A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA A /2 9.?42? 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A A5.; 63 A52?2 6@ ; 6;C2@A:2;A 6 2 @@B:6;4 A56@ 0;16A6; 591@ D5605 6@ A?B2 3? /A5 :129@ 3 @20A6; 63 A52 6;0?2.@2 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 0.B@21 /F . 56452? D2645A 3? A52 6;0B:/2;AJ@ =?HA 6@ 56452? 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A A52 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A .?2 56452? 63 A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ . 56452? $; A52 A52? 5.;1 . ;24.A6C2 0.; ;9F /2 =@@6/92 63 6@ @BN062;A9F 56452? A5.; 3 ; A52 0;A?.?F A52; 6 2 D52;2C2? A52 ;24.A6C2 6:=.0A 3 . 56452? D2645A 3? 0;@B:2? @B?=9B@ 6; A52 .002@@ =?602 6@ 56452? 63 A52?2 6@ 6;C2@A:2;A A52 6;02;A6C2@ A 6;C2@A .?2 9D2? 63 A52 9246@9.A? @2A@ . 56452? $(2+ 3.192 $(2(.- 2;A2 /F A52 6;0?2:2;A.9 @06.9 D293.?2 3 6;C2@A :2;A 46C2; 2;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 6;C2@A:2;A 6;0?2.@2@ D293.?2 46C2; .;1 12;A2 /F A52 56452@A 92C29 3 A52 6;C2@A:2;A 0@A 3? D5605 A52 6;0B:/2;A 6;C2@A@ 46C2;