Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
  • Like
[PREMONEY 2014] Gunderson Dettmer >> Joshua Cook, "The Wind-Down Round: Navigating Liability When Startups Fail"
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.


Now you can save presentations on your phone or tablet

Available for both IPhone and Android

Text the download link to your phone

Standard text messaging rates apply

[PREMONEY 2014] Gunderson Dettmer >> Joshua Cook, "The Wind-Down Round: Navigating Liability When Startups Fail"


"The Wind-Down Round: Navigating Liability When Startups Fail" …

"The Wind-Down Round: Navigating Liability When Startups Fail"

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
No Downloads


Total Views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. Light at the end of tunnel . . .
  • 2. Series A Crunch??
  • 3. The Result??
  • 4. So What Are We Talking About? • Asset Sales • Wind Downs (Shut downs) • Recaps • Dissolving
  • 5. Asset Deals • Could be multiple asset sales – Patent Portfolio, platform, acqui-hires and more • Pros – Purchaser only assumes specified liabilities – No Purchaser shareholder vote required • Cons – Liabilities not specifically assumed by Purchaser remain with Seller • There are exceptions to even an asset purchaser’s ability to exclude certain types of liabilities, including certain taxes, product liabilities, environmental liabilities, ERISA liabilities and Cobra liabilities – Third party consents will likely be required (“assignment of contracts”) – Very difficult to meet tax-free requirements – but tax considerations likely not important – Post closing distributions and wind down matters
  • 6. Multiple Asset Deals • Difficulty separating IP assets • May need to negotiate license back for sale of remaining assets –Can be complicated with sale of patent portfolio
  • 7. Recaps
  • 8. Recaps Mechanics • Conversion – Convert existing preferred stock to common stock – may need some syndicate of non investing preferred investors to approve • Reduce preference overhang – investors will need to consider target preference post closing • Preserve (or restore) value of prior preference based upon participation – this is the exchange or “pull through” – Common Stock (from old preferred stock) exchanged for new preferred stock at exchange ratio tied to preference pull through • Effect reverse stock split of common stock – reduces old common and old preferred ownership
  • 9. Recaps Mechanics • Consult with company and investor counsel on fiduciary obligations (if board member) and ways to mitigate litigation exposure • Some key considerations: – Disinterested lead investor in new financing (if possible) – Clear record of thorough search for disinterested lead investor – Rights offering to all affected stockholders – Disinterested approval of special committee of board of directors – Disinterested stockholder approval – Price-based antidilution likely triggered – don’t forget to consider impact – Process and paperwork pricey
  • 10. Alternatives to Recaps Convertible Notes with Multiple on Sale • Simpler and cheaper paperwork • Still must consider “fairness” issues • Does not address preference overhang – Consider success bonus or carveout plans to address overhang – set aside portion of exit proceeds for employees who stick around • May be able to secure debt with Company assets – Consider existing lender rights
  • 11. Wind Downs • PREPARE PREPARE PREPARE • GET YOUR NUMBERS DOWN • And then do the numbers over again • And remember to run them without a “going concern” assumption
  • 12. Personal Liability
  • 13. Risks • YEP, IF YOU’RE ON THE BOARD OR AN OFFICER, YOUR PERSONAL ASSETS CAN BE AT RISK • Some key areas to ensure company counsel (or your counsel) locks down: – Unpaid wages (including vacation, benefits and other compensation) – Continued employment when the company doesn’t have the cash to pay – Use of taxes withheld from employees’ pay for other purposes – Nonpayment of unemployment, workers’ compensation, disability and other payroll-related taxes – Nonpayment of municipal, state sales and use taxes – WARN act issues
  • 14. Wind Downs How to manage: –Self-managed? –Assignment for benefit of creditors? –Bankruptcy filing? –Friendly foreclosure?
  • 15. Sample Checklist • Identify all bank accounts and money market accounts. Revisit signature authority • Identify all lease agreements. Identify associated security deposits, and consider negotiating to apply deposits to rent as it comes due. In hot market, consider terminating early • Identify and review material contracts, particularly contracts critical to the company’s continued operations. Identify contracts where the company is in default and evaluate penalties • Identify and review all secured loans • Identify continuing obligations (those that may survive sales, mergers or shutdowns) • Identify all prepaid expenses and try to recoup them • Collect and cancel all corporate credit cards
  • 16. Recap on the Wind Down • Communicate Communicate Communicate • I typically refer to interested parties as “Stakeholders” – Employees – Stockholders – Creditors – Bridge Note holders – Secured Creditors
  • 17. Recap on Wind Downs • Four Star Word Time – “Fiduciary obligations” – I’m an investor, so who do I look out for? Yourself – I’m also a board member, so what now? Oh yeah. Obligations owed to Company and stockholders – And creditors? Lawyers often advise D&Os on shifting obligations to creditors in “zone of insolvency” • BUT Delaware cases over the last few years have reduced (or eliminated) director duties to creditors • Nuanced advice: Maximize enterprise value without considering the effect on creditors • Not so nuanced advice: Be sure to understand stakeholders’ contractual rights • When can secured creditor trigger repayment? • When about remaining severance obligations?
  • 18. Who Should Lead the Charge on the Process? • Short Answer: Company management should manage process with guidance from Board • Longer harder answer: Oftentimes, management has no incentive to stick around. Conflicting stakeholder interests may make “by the book” process difficult • IMPORTANT TIP: VCs should not usurp functions of the Company board. But there’s nothing wrong with creditors negotiating • SUPER IMPORTANT REMINDER: COMMUNICATE COMMUNICATE COMMUNICATE
  • 19. A Note on “Dissolution” • Filing a “Certificate of Dissolution” only BEGINS the wind down process • Company continues to survive with limited authority to process wind down activities • Not unusual to forego filing Certificate of Dissolution – DE generally doesn’t pursue for franchise taxes • BUT be sure to withdraw registration in other states. CA will come looking for $$
  • 20. Contact Josh Cook, Gunderson Dettmer 650-463-5267 @joshcook Gunderson Dettmer 140 Second Street, Second Floor San Francisco CA p: 650-321-2400 Twitter: @gundersonlaw
  • 21. Gunderson Dettmer Stats • More than 2,000 company clients • More than 950 venture financings each year • More than 60 venture fund formations annually
  • 22. 500 Startups And, of course, >500 deals for